CouncilMonitor
194 principal councils 228,996 meetings since 2000 2.8 million official papers archived Straight from each council's own publication system
Liverpool City Council
Executive Board, Friday 19 August 2005

Indemnities for Members and Officers (RES/37)

Agreed Executive 1 paper

Executive Board agreed this item on Friday 19 August 2005. Below is the council's own wording, with the papers it was decided on.

Item40e

Resolved

Resolved that it be recommended to the City Council - (1) That an indemnity be given to members (including co-opted and advisory members, but not advisory members of Neighbourhood Committees) and officers which:- · Preserves the existing indemnity for former members and officers · Is given in general terms so as to cover all the circumstances envisaged by the Local Authorities (Indemnities for Members and Officers) Order 2004 · Covers successful challenges to allegations or findings of breaches of the Members’ Code of Conduct, so far as the Order allows. (2) That the Executive Board pass resolution in the following terms, and recommend the City Council to agree its inclusion in Financial Regulations in the City Council’s constitution:- (1) This resolution shall take effect from the date on which it is passed and in substitution for any previous indemnity resolution. In this resolution : - “employees” includes any person employed by the Council and any other person engaged or appointed to be an officer of the Council. ” members ” includes the co-opted members or advisory members of the Children’s Services Select Committee, Culture and Tourism Select Committee, Social Care and Health Select Committee, and the Standards Committee and of any Committee, or Sub Committee discharging the same or similar functions. (2) The Council hereby indemnifies its employees and members, whether appointed or elected at the date of this resolution or at any time thereafter, against the costs, claims and expenses set out in paragraph (3) of this resolution, subject to the exceptions set out in paragraph (4) of this resolution, and on the terms set out in paragraph (5) of this resolution. It will not itself make any claim against them in relation to any costs or expenses for which they are hereby indemnified. Notwithstanding any limitation on the powers of the Council, the indemnity is effective to the extent that the employee or member in question - (a) believed that the action, or failure to act, in question was within the powers of the Council, or (b) where that action or failure comprises the issuing or authorisation of any document containing any statement as to the powers of the Council, or any statement that certain steps have been taken or requirements fulfilled, believed that the contents of that statement were true, and it was reasonable for that employee or member to hold that belief at the time when he or she acted or failed to act. The indemnity is also effective in relation to any act or omission which is subsequently found to be beyond the powers of the employee or member in question but only to the extent that he or she reasonably believed that the act or omission in question was within his or her powers at the time at which he or she acted. (3) The costs, claims and expenses are those which arise from, or in connection with, any action of, or failure to act by, the employee or member in question, which:- (a) is or has ...
Word for word from the decision Liverpool published for this meeting. Source: councillors.liverpool.gov.uk

Follow this further

Built from Liverpool's papers

What the report saysPro

Report to Executive Board, 11 pages

Executive summary

Introduction

1. Members and Officers can find themselves at risk of personal liability for their activities: criminal liability (for manslaughter or the proposed corporate killing offence, for example), civil liability under contracts or for negligence, liability because of their relationship with an outside body (typically as a company director or a trustee). Surcharge has been abolished, but members may now be charged with breaches of their Code of Conduct, even if they are innocent, and have to defend themselves. For centuries the law has recognised that this can be unreasonable, and sought to provide safeguards.

2. First, there are common law safeguards derived from the relationship between a corporate body and its members, and an employee and his or her employer. Secondly, there have been limited statutory safeguards for over 150 years, still principally to be found in section 265 of the Public Health Act 1875. Then, in the 1970s and 1980s, the context in which local authorities operated became more complex, and authorities themselves became more entrepreneurial. The Association of Metropolitan Authorities circulated the text of a resolution for local authorities to adopt which offered an indemnity to their members and officers against personal liability for their activities in connection with the authority, unless they had acted dishonestly. Many local authorities adopted this resolution, or a variation on it crafted by their legal advisers. The City Council has such an indemnity resolution in its constitution, within its Financial Regulations. The terms of this resolution are set out at the end of the recommendation.

3. The 1990s saw a raft of cases where District Auditors and the Courts bore down on some of the more marginal and imaginative activities of some authorities, who discovered that they lacked legal power to undertake them. In the landmark case of Burgoine and Cooke in 1996, Waltham Forest LBC had set up a joint venture company to build and run a water park, which failed disastrously. The two officers whom it had appointed to the board were sued for wrongful trading, and attempted to claim indemnity based on an AMA style resolution. The District Auditor objected, and, to most people’s surprise at the time, the Court held that Waltham Forest lacked the legal power to set up and fund the joint venture in the way that it had, and that consequently the indemnity could not be given.

4. A few years later, though, the judgement in the Westminster City Council case ex parte Legge in 2000 established beyond doubt that local authorities could, in some circumstances at least, offer valid indemnities to officers and members under their general powers in section 111 of the Local Government Act 1972.

5. Nevertheless, some uncertainty remained. There were three grey areas. First, it is now commonplace for authorities to enter into partnerships with other commercial, public sector or community bodies. Government recommends it, and often requires it. Officers and members are placed on external bodies, to run them, and, in a variety of different senses, to represent the authority. It was not clear how far personal liability arising from participation in outside bodies could be indemnified by the authority, especially if (as in Burgoine and Cooke) there was a conflict of interest between the outside body and the authority. Why should the Council be allowed to indemnify a company director who had done something which was against the Council’s interest?

Read every report as text, not just the decision

Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.

Papers for this item

Kept in our archive, download once signed in
PDF
Indemnities for Members and Officers (RES/37)Report 11 pages DownloadRead as text

At this meeting

Whole meeting

Who was there

11 of 16 attended
MS
Councillor Mike Storey CBEChair, apologies
DA
Councillor Dave AntrobusMember, present
WB
Councillor Warren BradleyMember, present
PC
Councillor Paul CleinMember, present
FC
Councillor Flo Clucas OBEMember, present
MF
Councillor Marilyn FieldingMember, apologies
RM
Councillor Richard MarbrowMember, present
PM
Councillor Peter MilleaMember, present
RO
Councillor Richard OglethorpeMember, present
KT
Councillor Keith TurnerMember, present
SD
Sir David HenshawOfficer, present
PH
Phil HalsallOfficer, apologies

All 16 on the meeting page

On this subject at Liverpool

Search all
  1. Indemnities for Members and Officers (RES/37)This decision
  2. Indemnities for members and officersAgreed
  3. Indemnities for Members and OfficersAgreed

More from Liverpool Executive Board

All decisions
MeetingDecisionOutcome
23 Apr 2010 Minutes of the Last MeetingResolved that the minutes of the meeting held on 9 April 2010 be approved as a true record. Approved Open
23 Apr 2010 New Growth Point - Revised Programme of Development (SSC/43)Resolved that - (i) authority be granted for capital and revenue projects as identified as ‘Priority 1’ in Appendix 1... Decided Open
23 Apr 2010 2010/11 Housing Market Renewal Fund (HMRF) (SSC/44)Resolved that - (i) authority be granted for the Executive Director (Regeneration) to accept a Housing Market Renewal... Decided Open
23 Apr 2010 Refresh of Children and Young People's Plan 2010/11 (ESE/41)Resolved that it be recommended to the City Council that the recommendation and views of the Education and Skills Sel... Approved Open
23 Apr 2010 Croxteth Primary New Build School - Final Business Case (ESE/42)Resolved that - (i) in accordance with the decision (Minute No. 50(b)) of the Executive Board of 12 September 2008 th... Approved Open

We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies