Resolved that the minutes be noted and that the suggestion in Minute No. 4 relating to the Review of the Forward Plan New Entries that in future the Executive Member recommendation template be altered to request that a reason is clearly given to the Board when items have not appeared in the Forward Plan be approved.
Word for word from the decision Liverpool published for this meeting.Source: councillors.liverpool.gov.uk
PRESENT: Councillor Erica Kemp (Chair) Councillor Laurence Sidorczuk (Deputy Chair) Councillors Paul Brant, Alan Dean, Kevin Firth, Ron Gould, Janet Kent, Andrew Makinson, Barbara Murray and Hazel Williams
EXECUTIVE MEMBER Councillor Dave Antrobus
EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR Phil Halsall
APOLOGIES: Councillors Eddie Clein and Peter Millea
OFFICERS: Ian McFarlane (Assistant Executive Director - Scrutiny and Best Value) and Chris Walsh (Head of Committee & Member Services) _____
1. Declarations of Interest
Members/Officers were given an opportunity to declare a personal or prejudicial interest in any matter on the Agenda.
Councillor Erica Kemp declared a personal interest in item 8 – Update on Corporate Assessment by virtue of her work undertaken on behalf of the IdEA.
Councillor Alan Dean declared a personal interest in item 8 – Update on Corporate Assessment by virtue of his work undertaken on behalf of the IdEA.
2. Minutes of the Last Meeting
Agreed the minutes of the last meeting held on 3 April 2007 be approved as a true record subject to the apologies for absence being submitted by Councillor Erica Kemp being reflected therein. 3. Draft Work Programme
The Committee considered the draft work programme for the Select Committee for the Municipal Year 2007/08.
Members raised the following issues –
(a) The need to ensure that the Chairs and Deputy Chairs enrol and go through the scrutiny module; (b) The recent review of AEM roles by the independent remuneration panel on members allowances; (c) The scrutiny of the progress with the neighbourhood governance agenda to be looked at in January 2008; and (d) The arrangements and resources available in terms of scrutiny, commissioning, technical, expert and independent advice as deemed appropriate.
The chair responded and stated that in terms of specialist and independent advice there would need to be some cost and benefit analysis re individual cases and a budget identified. The Chair indicated that she would bring something back on this issue in October.
The Chair also stated that the role of AEM’s could be picked up in the discussions to be arranged in the meeting between select committee Chairs and the Executive Members.
Agreed that –
(a) the draft work programme be approved; (b) all Chairs and Deputy Chairs be reminded of the need to undertake the scrutiny training module; and (c) the Chair be requested to report back in October regarding budget and external advice.
4. Review of the Forward Plan New Entries
The Committee considered a report on the continuing action being taken to increase the number of new entries being published in the Forward Plan.
Members raised the following key issues –
(a) disappointment at the fact there are still almost 50% of key decisions taken by the Executive Board not being published in the Forward Plan; (b) the importance of ensuring that local ward councillors are given due consideration in terms of consultation on key decisions and therefore feature in the Forward Plan; (c) the need for those matters which may be deemed to be sensitive that appear late or not at all in the Forward Plan that opposition spokespersons are advised of such issues; and (d) there needs to be a clear reason given to why the matter was not in the Forward Plan by the officer and the Executive Member.
Chris Walsh outlined the fact that there were representatives in each portfolio feeding items into the Forward Plan. This is a key issue to be picked up corporately to ensure that officers are both aware of the requirements and that they comply. This is a key item also being discussed by Executive Members and the Executive Team on a regular basis.
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.