Resolved that – (i) the tender for the eradication of dry rot and associated works at Gilmour Junior School from E. Ratcliffe Ltd. in the sum of £604,362 be accepted and the City Council enter into a contract for the works; (ii) 2o2o Liverpool Limited’s fees of £72,523 (12%) be accepted, together with City Council residual charges of £8,703; and (iii) the Capital Programme be amended accordingly. NH/19
Word for word from the decision Liverpool published for this meeting.Source: councillors.liverpool.gov.uk
Extensive dry rot has attacked timbers in a number of ground floor and first floor rooms in the eastern wing of the school including parts of the corridor. To treat the outbreak it is necessary to remove and replace affected floor timbers, doorframes and skirting, hack off and renew plasterwork and subsequently refurbish the affected rooms.
Mechanical and electrical systems are surface fixed to walls within the school and consequently will also have to be taken down and subsequently renewed, necessitating a partial re-wire and replacement of heating and water pipe work.
The project will take 26 weeks to complete and the school will be decanting a number of classes into 2 temporary mobile units for the duration of the works. During the summer 2007 some enabling works were undertaken in advance of the main project which involved repairs to the main drainage runs underneath the school playground and running underneath the building – the principle source of water for the dry rot, and the removal of asbestos in the main heating floor duct.
In accordance with Standing Orders and the Corporate Procurement Unit’s procedures an advert was placed on the City Council’s Website and the local Chamber of Commerce Website and tenders requested from suitable contractors.
Four tenders were returned by the closing date of 29th November 2008. The lowest initial tender was from Walsh Construction Ltd. in the sum of £375,310. This was significantly below other tenders and also significantly below 20:20 Liverpool’s budget estimates for the project. Following requests to the two lowest contractors to submit a priced schedule of works Walsh Construction Ltd subsequently withdrew their tender. The second lowest tender received was from E. Ratcliffe Ltd. in the sum of £604,362. The priced schedule of works has been checked by 20:20 Liverpool and confirmed to be arithmetically correct and it is therefore recommended that this tender be accepted and the City Council enter into a contract for the works.
Executive Director recommendation: Stuart Smith recommends that:
(i) the tender for the eradication of dry rot and associated works at Gilmour Junior School from E. Ratcliffe Ltd. in the sum of £604,362 be accepted and the City Council enter into a contract for the works;
(ii) 20:20 Liverpool Fees of £72,523 (12%) be accepted, together with City Council residual charges of £8,703; and
(iii) the Capital Programme be amended accordingly.
Key Decision: Yes
Forward Plan: Yes
Implementation effective from: 25 January 2008
Timescale for action: Works shall commence upon completion of the contract which is anticipated to be February 2008 and will take up to 26 weeks for completion.
Reason(s) for Recommendation:
The effective eradication of the dry rot requires the extensive works outlined in the report. The school has endeavoured to deal with the problem on a piecemeal basis over the last few years but this has failed to adequately treat the problem or the cause.
Alternative options considered
Leaving the problem unchecked will only lead to the rot becoming more extensive and spreading throughout other areas of the school leading to further deterioration of the building fabric and ultimately additional cost to remedy and more disruption to the pupils and staff. Consultation: The project has been developed in agreement with the school and governing body.
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.