Resolved that - (i) the potential liability of the City Council to successful claims for equal pay be acknowledged; (ii) the arrangements for the settlement of claims relating to equal pay outlined in the report submitted be approved and that the Chief Executive and the Interim Executive Director (Finance & Legal Services) be granted authority to determine the matrix agreement and enact the required procedures; and (iii) the decision be referred to the Corporate Services Select Committee for scrutiny.
Word for word from the decision Liverpool published for this meeting.Source: councillors.liverpool.gov.uk
Portfolio: Corporate Performance/ Executive Member/Director: Finance and Europe Cllr S Hurst and Cllr F Clucas, OBE / Peter Cosgrove and Robert Corbett
Date of submission: Subject: Equal Pay 10th October 2008
Report No./Background papers: Contact Officer: Elizabeth Topping List of relevant jobs for Phase 1 Equal Pay Project Manager Tel: 225 2852 Email: [email protected]
Executive summary: This report sets out the history of the national Equal Pay issue that has affected most councils in the country and sets out the proposed mechanism for resolving the issue in Liverpool.
1 History: 1.1 The National 1988 Job Evaluation Scheme provided grades for manual jobs based on objective criteria. Local agreements extended these grades and criteria. However, after this point in time, it is claimed that manual occupations predominantly filled by men came to receive a higher remuneration than those occupations predominantly filled by women. This additional remuneration was in the form of supplements, such as payment of; bonus; attendance allowance, more favourable overtime rates, unsocial hours allowances, and wet weather payments.
1.2However, the key issue is that a number of the elements of additional remuneration may not all be objectively justified by the City Council. A situation that is replicated in councils up and down the country. In these circumstances the occupations receiving the additional remuneration become potential comparators for the purpose of substantiating claims for equal pay from other employees and eligible previous employees.
1.3Claims relating to Equal Pay began to be made across the country from the late 1990s onwards. In November 2006 the City Council received grievances and subsequent Employment Tribunal claims relating to claims for equal pay from employees either direct, or with the support of their recognised trade union. The grievances and claims relate to a comparison with a range of manual jobs within the City Council or previously within the City Council. The claims give a range (but not exhaustive) of potential job titles.
1.4These claims are referred to as the historical claims which are to be distinguished from the other claims which it is hoped can be dealt with primarily as part of the City Council’s commitment to Single Status. In any event, the allegations are of inequality between men and women which exposes the City Council to potential liability if the individual employee or former employee claiming can identify and rely upon a valid comparator.
2 Present position: 2.1 Other local authorities have sought to provide for an arrangement undertaken in consultation with ACAS.
2.2The arrangement established is to reach an agreement with the employees, or their representatives including a financial payment in settlement of their claim/potential claim. The sum being derived from a matrix agreement based upon length of service and average weekly hours worked.
2.3The matrix arrangements that have been implemented locally (Merseyside and Greater Manchester) have tended to have a reasonable consistency in terms of the values offered and what has been accepted. The intention is therefore to follow the example of other authorities.
2.4To fund such payments a request was made to the government to capitalise payments made during 2008/09 relating to equal pay in accordance with the accounting and financing arrangements the government has specifically established for such purposes . On 26th September 2008 the government confirmed an allowance for borrowings sufficient for the City Council to capitalise the likely cost of payments made during the current financial year.
3 Phasing and relevant jobs 3.1 The City Council needs therefore to consider making compensation payments where appropriate to the affected existing employees and previous employees in order to minimise the City Council’s potential liability.
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.