Item7
Resolved
Resolved that having considered all of the evidence and submissions presented, and having regard to the application made by the appellants, the Panel has decided to disallow the appeal. The appellants claimed that the duties and responsibilities of the post have substantially increased since 1997, due to various factors, including but not limited to, the requirement to undertake internal fraud investigation, the requirement to conduct formal interviews under caution, the introduction of national training standards and the significant development in the regulatory framework. The appellants also sought to compare their role with that of other roles within the authority at a higher grade. Management submitted that whilst the job has evolved over the years, there is no evidence to support an increase in duties and responsibilities to merit a re-grade. The Panel considered the various key factors in support of the appellants application and made the following findings of fact – i) the requirement to undertake internal investigation without having to decide on disciplinary issues had not increased the responsibility of the post. ii) the requirement to conduct interviews under caution had been an essential duty of the post since 1999. iii) the significant developments in the regulatory framework for local authority benefit fraud had not increased the complexity of the post iv) the higher graded posts identified within the authority were not comparable in relation to the duties undertaken Having regard to the above facts and circumstances, the Panel resolved that there was no evidence to support the application for a re-grade based on an increase in duties and responsibilities. The decision of the Panel is final and there is no further internal right of appeal.
Word for word from the decision Liverpool published for this meeting.
Source: councillors.liverpool.gov.uk