RESOLVED (i) That the report on the outcome of the Committee’s work on this Member Scrutiny Request item be noted; (ii) That the Council identified any actions arising from the Committee’s conclusions to inform practice and process in relation to future similar corporate projects.
Word for word from the decision Maldon published for this meeting.Source: democracy.maldon.gov.uk
1.1The purpose of this report is to inform the Council of the outcome of the Overview and Scrutiny Committee’s (the Committee) work on this matter.
Recommendation
(i) That the report on the outcome of the Committee’s work on this Member Scrutiny Request item is received and noted;
(ii) That the Council identifies any actions arising from the Committee’s conclusions to inform practice and process in relation to future similar corporate projects.
3. SUMMARY OF KEY ISSUES
3.1The Committee on 25 April 2024 first considered a report from its Working Group on this scrutiny item request submitted by Councillor A S Fluker. The request sought a review of various issues arising from the extensive history of this corporate project which was effectively closed by the Council by decision at its meeting in November 2023.
3.2This project involved the potential acquisition of land by the Council with a view to providing affordable housing and generating a commercial return. The Overview and Scrutiny Working Group (the Working Group) continued to request and consider further information to understand the various issues raised by and as a consequence of the scrutiny request, so that it could reach an informed conclusion for report back to the Committee.
3.3During that process it was noted that the project team had undertaken a ‘lessons learned’ workshop and the resulting report prepared was awaiting sign-off by the Corporate Leadership Team following which it could be shared with Members. The scrutiny request having been added to the Committee’s workplan, the Working Group was subsequently tasked with reviewing the ’lessons learned’ report and recommending further to the Committee.
3.4The ‘lessons learned’ report having been noted and already shared with Members, the Committee would be invited to note that it would inform practice and process for similar projects in the future. Whilst the report recorded the things the Council did well, it set out some areas for learning as follows:
Our Vision: Where Quality of Life Matters 3.4.1 Areas for learning on future projects:
3.4.1.1 Although the project did proceed initially on the basis of internal planning advice, it is felt that Maldon District Council (MDC) must ensure that any future development opportunities start with a robust and clearly documented assessment of site viability, taken forward via a series of ‘approval gateways’ overseen / agreed by both Officers and Members at each stage. The below process is recommended to ensure early identification of site viability / risks and engagement of Members: 1) Carry out an initial planning appraisal as to whether the Council is in a position to take forward / explore a proposal(s) for housing development in light of the Maldon Local Development Plan, the Spatial Strategy and where that development may be situated relative the settlement boundary. 2) Conduct a Planning Sustainability Assessment of identified site (including multiple site options (where these are available) 3) Develop a high-level Concept Design (in order to commence early-stage planning appraisal, land valuation and pre-app) 4) Land Valuation (Red Book) 5) Planning appraisal with key statutory consultees e.g., Essex County Council Highways and Education, Environment Agency etc. 6) Hold an early Pre-App with Members with a draft scheme to identify potential issues and secure a more collaborative culture between Members and Officers.
3.5A report was brought back to the Committee at its meeting on 24 September 2024. This outlined the further discussion undertaken by the Working Group, focusing on how the project was instigated and perpetuated only to be found not to be commercially viable. Officers maintained that they had engaged with Members throughout and in the interests of good governance had obtained approval to necessary important steps.
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.