Councillor B Toomey led Cabinet through the report. RESOLVED 1. That Cabinet recommend the policy to Council for adoption in relation to roadside memorials or tributes. 2. That Cabinet approve Option 2 as set out in the report and manage the issue in an appropriate and sensitive manner such that: · No permanent roadside memorials will be authorised. · Floral tributes and their location will be allowed under conditions to be determined by the Director of Customer Corporate Services, taking into account highway safety, operational maintenance and the interest of any residents local to the site of the intended location. · Floral tributes should not be permanently planted features. · Floral tributes will be allowed to remain in place for a maximum of three months. · Anniversary floral tributes will be allowed under the same conditions as 2, 3 and 4 above. FURTHER RESOLVED 1. In the event that a request for ashes to be spread on the Council’s open land (e.g. a highway verge or similar) the request will usually be approved. The Council cannot however guarantee that ashes distributed in this fashion will not be disturbed in future. No interment of ashes will be permitted in the Council’s open land. 2. In circumstances when the bereaved family do request a permanent memorial, it may be possible to satisfy such requests by encouraging the provision of benches, trees or similar away from the highway. To this end the Council would/will co-operate in the dedication of park benches and/or trees etc. in public open spaces or parks.
Word for word from the decision Merthyr Tydfil published for this meeting.Source: democracy.merthyr.gov.uk
1.1Councillors will have noticed that there is an increasing prevalence for the provision of roadside memorials at locations where fatal road accidents have occurred. This appears to be a national trend and not merely a local phenomenon. Within Merthyr Tydfil County Borough Council most of the fatal collisions have taken place on the trunk roads A470, A465 and A4060. The Council is not the Highway Authority responsible for these roads and decisions about roadside memorials on these will be for the Welsh Assembly Government to make. However as the placing of floral tributes at the site of a fatal collision is becoming common practice and this is likely to continue until an effective alternative is found, the Council will need to formulate a Policy for roads for which it is the Highway Authority.
1.2In addition, it has been noticed elsewhere that permanent memorials, in the form of stones or signs, are being placed on highway land. Whilst this has not happened within the County Borough we would not wish to encourage such memorials by not taking positive action to deter them. There is already a degree of unauthorised signing on the Council’s roads and any late decision to remove memorial stones or signs could place the Council in a very negative light.
1.3The issue is highly sensitive and it is suggested that if the Council fails to respond promptly, the public would see this lack of action as tacit approval. Therefore, the longer the present situation goes on the harder it will be for the Council to introduce a Policy that either deters or allows such practices, without appearing insensitive or uncaring. It is important that any Policy does not compromise the Council’s stance on removing other obstructions within the highway.
1.4The Council needs to address how it responds to this apparently ever increasing trend, in a manner which effectively deals with the safety and maintenance issues whilst not appearing insensitive to the needs of victims’ families. 1.5 For many, the need to recognise the tragedy and demonstrate its significance publicly leads families to consider a roadside memorial in addition to the victim’s final resting-place. Regardless of any personal views, this is a real issue that requires a corporate response.
1.6The placing of floral tributes only should also be subject to a formalised Policy, although their presence tends to be in the short-term (normally removed by cleansing staff once the flowers have died naturally or following a period of inclement weather).
1.7As far as I am aware, neighbouring Local Authorities, and indeed the Welsh Assembly Government do not have a Policy in this matter.
2. Options available to the Council
Option 1
An “outright” ban on both floral tributes and any permanent roadside memorials on safety grounds.
If such floral tributes/memorials are placed within the highway, the Council will remove them to its stores for collection by family relatives.
If the same floral tributes/memorials are replaced within the highway, action under the Council’s powers on removal of obstructions within the highway will be taken which could lead to prosecution through the Courts.
Option 2
Manage the issue in an appropriate and sensitive manner such that:
1. No permanent roadside memorials will be authorised.
2. Floral tributes and their location will be allowed under conditions to be determined by the Director of Customer Corporate Services, taking into account highway safety, operational maintenance and the interest of any residents local to the site of the intended location.
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.