RESOLVED that 1 no. P2N15 refuse vehicle be purchased from Dennis Eagle Ltd., Heathcote Way, Heathcote Industrial Estate, Warwick, CV34 6TE, with the Bin Lift being awarded to Zoeller Waste Systems, 5 Colemeadow Road, Redditch at a total cost of £121,355. 1 no., dedicated gritting chassis vehicle be purchased from Euro Commercials (South Wales) Ltd., Ipswich Road, Cardiff, CF23 9AQ and Econ Engineering Ltd., Boroughbridge Road, Ripon, North Yorkshire, HG4 1UE for the Body and Plough at a total cost of £103, 535.39.
Word for word from the decision Merthyr Tydfil published for this meeting.Source: democracy.merthyr.gov.uk
DATE WRITTEN 18th December 2008 REPORT AUTHOR Paul Davies HEAD OF SERVICE Hugh O’Sullivan COMMITTEE DIVISION Portfolio COMMITTEE Cabinet COMMITTEE DATE 14th January 2009
TO: Chairman, Ladies and Gentlemen
PURCHASE OF VEHICLES
PURPOSE OF REPORT: To seek Cabinet Approval for the purchase of 1 no. Refuse Collection Vehicle & 1 6x6 Dedicated Gritting Vehicle
1.0INTRODUCTION AND BACKGROUND
1.1Following the Fleet procurement cabinet report dated 6th September 2006, it was agreed to implement several changes within Fleet management to allow use of All Wales collaborative frameworks for the procurement of the Council’s large goods fleet which was detailed in the approved business case.
1.2The All Wales collaborative frameworks are compliant frameworks created to reduce administration and increase efficiencies through the procurement process. The frameworks have been identified as providing additional cost benefits over traditional tendering exercises, both on the overall cost of vehicles and the costs of managing tenders.
2.0VEHICLE REQUIREMENTS
2.1There is a requirement to replace 1 refuse vehicle and 1 gritting vehicle within the next financial year.
Registration Type Lease End VX51 GSV Dennis Eagle P2N15 31/03/2009 X243 CTX Scania/Schmidt Gritter 31/03/2009 2.2 The specification of the refuse vehicle is such to allow for collection in the narrow streets of the County Borough. Therefore ‘narrow’ chassis are specified. Our current supplier of Refuse vehicles are the only manufacturer to offer narrow chassis, and this directly supports our ongoing maintenance contract with their servicing department based locally. The Framework was engaged directly to obtain a cost of the replacement chassis and body as follows :- P2N15 Refuse Collection Vehicle - £105,430
2.5A mini competition was held to evaluate the bin lift requirements. Three companies were requested to quote, from the All Wales Framework. One company declined to submit. There are only 3 manufacturers on the framework able to supply the split lift required for domestic and trade combination collections. The prices submitted were
Company A £15,925 Company B £16,850
2.6The evaluation was based on set criteria from the framework, the scores were as follows:- Company A Company B Evaluation Criteria Weight Score Total Score Total Policies (e.g. Health & Safety etc) 1 4 4 4 4 Compliance 3 4 12 4 12 Quality 4 5 20 4 16 Price & Associated Costs 5 5 25 4 20 Delivery 3 4 12 5 15 After Sales & Support 4 4 16 5 20 Total Score 89 87
2.7The recommended supplier therefore is Company A, based on the evaluation of criteria set out in the framework and the final submitted price.
2.8The total cost of the refuse vehicle is £121,355
Gritting Vehicle
2.9The chassis for the gritting vehicle was selected from the framework based on best value for money. The chassis is a dedicated gritter chassis and built solely for that purpose. This ensures that the whole vehicle is fit for purpose and offers best value over the life of the vehicle. The cost of the chassis with all required options is £70,593.
2.10The gritting vehicle body is to be supplied by Econ Engineering who specialise in gritting vehicles, with no other manufacturer offering the 9cu mt body to our specification on the All Wales Framework. The body price includes the powered plough. The cost of the gritting equipment is £32,942.39
2.11The total cost of the gritting vehicle is £103,535.39 3.0 FINANCIAL IMPLICATIONS
3.1The vehicles detailed in this report are direct replacements and will be leased via operating leases and the costs associated with their acquisition will be met out of client department revenue budgets. 3.2 Any efficiencies identified will be recorded on the Benefits Recording Model.
4.0RECOMMENDATIONS that
i. 1 no. P2N15 Refuse Vehicle be purchased from Dennis Eagle Ltd, Heathcote Way, Heathcote Industrial Estate, Warwick, CV34 6TE, with the Bin Lift being awarded to Zoeller Waste Systems, 5 Colemeadow Road, Redditch, at a total cost of £121,355
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.