Resolved
That t his Council supports and promotes the most effective and robust scrutiny process possible for Children and Young People, particularly given the vulnerable groups involved, the Ofsted requirement for effective scrutiny and the recommendations from the 2006 Leach Review of Overview and Scrutiny in Merton and the 2009 follow up report by Professor Leach which found that there was “much to commend about the approach to overview and scrutiny in Merton”, with our performance comparing favourably to other authorities assessed. Whilst respecting the independence of the scrutiny function and the panels’ responsibility for their own work programmes and ways of carrying this out most effectively, this Council resolves to ask if the Children and Young People O&S panel would like to consider any of the following suggestions, some of which they have considered previously or already incorporate in their work: 1) As it does at the start of each municipal year, consider whether it wishes to select one or more co-opted members with relevant professional experience outside the Borough; 2) consider whether to ask the departments to provide more detailed recommendations to guide and focus debate, bearing in mind that this may have resource implications for already overstretched departmental officers managing frontline service delivery to residents; 3) whether they wish to receive fuller executive summaries from departments to aid understanding, bearing in mind the caveat in 2, above; 4) whether they wish to take greater advantage of already strong Scrutiny officer support in the form of recommended questions and areas of focus, an approach that is already working well; and 5) as they already do when convening workshops, or undertaking task groups, consider whether they wish the opportunity to invite expert witnesses from outside the Borough for one or more meetings because they have a particular expertise in matters being scrutinised.