RESOLVED to: 1. Note the answers to questions raised at the earlier meeting; 2. Note and endorse the current Anti-Fraud and Corruption Policy; Housing and Council Tax Benefit Fraud Policy; and Fraud Policy & Procedure Manual; 3. Support the promotion of propriety in public office; 4 Review the Fraud Investigation Policy used by Torbay Council. Proposed by Cllr N A Way and seconded by Councillor T W Snow) Note : - Report previously circulated and attached to minutes.
Word for word from the decision Mid Devon published for this meeting.Source: democracy.middevon.gov.uk
Proceedings against Councillor Wilson – response to questions raised from Councillor Pugsley Responsible officer: Kevin Finan, Chief Executive
Reason for Report: The report was requested by the Scrutiny Committee meeting on 19 January 2015 to answer a series of questions raised by Members on the successful prosecution of Councillor Wilson in February 2014.
RECOMMENDATION: That the Scrutiny Committee:
1. Note the answers to their questions raised at the earlier meeting 2. Note and endorse the current Anti-Fraud and Corruption Policy; Housing and Council Tax Benefit Fraud Policy; and Fraud Policy & Procedure Manual (attached) 3. Support the promotion of propriety in public office
Relationship to Corporate Plan: Delivery of the Corporate Plan requires the Council maintaining public confidence and support. When exercising a community leadership role it is vital that the holders of public office act in a way that promotes propriety in their corporate culture.
Financial Implications: None arising directly from this report. The £3,800 benefit fraudulently claimed is being repaid by instalment. The costs of prosecution are explained within the report.
Legal Implications: None arising directly from this report. The Council’s powers and duties are covered in the appendices to the report.
Risk Assessment: The prevention and detection of fraud and corruption are managed through the maintenance of the Anti-Fraud and Corruption Policy and the Housing and Council Tax Benefit Fraud Policy. Failure to have and maintain such policies would leave the Council more vulnerable to fraudulent and corrupt activity.
1.0Introduction
1.1At the last meeting of this Committee, Councillor Pugsley raised a number of questions which the Chief Executive undertook to answer by way of a report to the next Committee meeting.
1.2Reference was made to a more recent prosecution case in the Exeter Magistrates Court costing £13k. This prosecution was brought by the Department for Work and Pensions and, as such, is not dealt with in this report.
1.3The Council maintains a number of policies and procedural processes to guide prosecution decisions when dealing with fraud and corruption. These are attached. MDDC Report: proceedings against Cllr Wilson V2 • Anti-Fraud and Corruption Policy – Appendix 1 • Housing and Council Tax Benefit Fraud Policy – Appendix 2 • Fraud Policy and Procedures Manual – Appendix 3
2.0Questions asked by Cllr Pugsley and Scrutiny Committee members
2.1A transcript of the last meeting giving details of the questions raised is attached at Appendix 4.
2.2Costs of the prosecution of Councillor Wilson for dishonesty.
2.2.1 The estimated costs of the prosecution have been put at £13,000. This covers the Council’s staff time in addition to the £10,000 cost of a barrister to represent the Council in the Crown Court.
2.2.2 Of the £3,000 estimated that the Council incurred, less than £1,000 was incurred in bringing the matter to the Exeter Magistrates Court.
2.2.3 The Council’s Solicitor for the case recorded 62.2 hours in total on the case, at a salary cost of £23 per hour, equalling £1,430. If we were charging out his time, it would be at a rate of £125 per hour.
2.2.4 The matter was taken to the Crown Court because Councillor Wilson pleaded not guilty at the Magistrates Court and elected to be tried at the Crown Court. As the Council employs only solicitors and not barristers, then our staff have no right of audience in the Crown Court. The necessity of employing a barrister to represent the Council was therefore entirely a consequence of Councillor Wilson’s refusal to plead guilty at an early stage in the proceedings.
2.3The employment of an expensive barrister.
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.