RESOLVED that · The owner be advised that the regular domestic mowing of an agricultural field may constitute a breach of planning control and the Council will monitor the use of the site over the spring/summer period to ensure a predominantly agricultural use is maintained on the land. · No further action be taken at this time. (Proposed Cllr Mrs H Bainbridge and seconded by Cllr P F Williams) Notes: Cllr E G Luxton declared a Disclosable Pecuniary Interest as his son was the landowner in question and left the meeting during the discussion thereon; Cllrs A V G Griffiths and D J Knowles declared personal interests as the landowner was known to them; [name removed] (neighbour) spoke; Cllrs A V G Griffiths, R L Stanley and K D Wilson requested that their abstention from voting was recorded.
Word for word from the decision Mid Devon published for this meeting.Source: democracy.middevon.gov.uk
Case No. ENF 14/00124/UDRU Grid Ref: 290886 112555
Address: Land west of Rowey Bungalow, Plainfield Lane, Withleigh,Tiverton.
Alleged Breach: Without planning permission, an unauthorised change of use has been undertaken namely the change of use of agricultural land to domestic garden.
Recommendation: 1. The owner be advised that the regular domestic mowing of an agricultural field may constitute a breach of planning control and the Council will monitor the use of the site over the spring/ summer period to ensure a predominantly agricultural use is maintained on the land. 2. No further action be taken at this time.
Site Description: Rowey Bungalow, Plainfield Lane, Withleigh, Tiverton is a detached bungalow to the west of Withleigh Village Hall. To the west of the residential bungalow and garden is an area of agricultural land the subject of this report.
Site Plan: Development Plan Policies: DM 31 – Planning Enforcement
Reasons/Material Considerations:
Rowey Bungalow was built as an agricultural workers dwelling in the 1970`s. The agricultural occupancy condition was breached for a period in excess of ten years and a Certificate of Lawful Existing Use was issued which allows the lawful occupation of the property without compliance with the occupancy condition. Additionally an area of land to the south of Rowey Bungalow was granted a Certificate of Lawful Existing Use as garden following a breach of planning control for a period in excess of 10 years the certificate now permits the land to the south to be used as garden.
The agricultural land the West of the bungalow was formally separated from the dwelling and curtilage by way of a fence which was removed. Following a complaint in 2005, that the land was being used for domestic purpose, the alleged breach was investigated under ENF/05/00123/UCU. Part of the fence was replaced to form a partial barrier between the field and the Rowey Bungalow curtilage. In 2005 it was considered no breach had occurred at that time as the land was not used principally for a domestic purpose and that the removal of a physical barrier was not in itself a breach.
In 2011 following further complaints about the use and domestic maintenance regime of cutting and mowing the area regularly further investigations took place. Again it was alleged that the land was again being used for domestic purpose. The land at that time was maintained by the current owner, by regular mowing and strimming, it was not considered at that time that it was cut to a level that would be considered domestic and no paraphernalia associated with a domestic use was sited on the land. Therefore it was concluded that a change of use has not occurred at that time. The land owner confirmed that in his view the land was in agricultural use at the time.
Since 2011 further complaints have been received about the use and maintenance regime of the land to the west of Rowey Bungalow. A Planning Contravention Notice was issued in 2014 and that was returned by the owner stating the land was in agricultural use. Following the receipt of that Notice a further letter was sent to the owner asking the nature of the agricultural activities carried out on the land. A response was received at the end of 2014 stating that the land was used for keeping chickens and ducks.
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.