That Cabinet confirms the decision of the 6 September “That it be agreed to increase the current loan agreements by a total of £2,280,784 to cover; the identified project overspends on 2 projects included in the previously agreed Business Plan funding envelope agreed on the 30 November 2021 and increased the working capital loan agreement. In addition, it be agreed that a transfer from a future projects budget of £0.58m in order for the business to work up new potential projects to replace the out of District projects that had to be removed from the company’s business plan after changes to the Treasury’s Public Works Loan Board loan arrangements.” (Proposed by the Leader) (Councillor S Penny Abstained) Note: The Cabinet Member for Finance announced that he had become an independent councillor with immediate effect.
Word for word from the decision Mid Devon published for this meeting.Source: democracy.middevon.gov.uk
Extracts from Draft Minutes – Scrutiny 21 September 2022 Decisions of the Cabinet – Minute 27
Call in – 3RDL Funding Request – By Cllr S J Clist – Chairman
At the Cabinet on 6 September 2022, Members considered the funding request that has been received from 3 Rivers Development Ltd.
Following discussion with various Officers, including a detailed conversation with the Monitoring Officer on Thursday 8 September, I am requesting that this item is called into the next Scrutiny meeting. I believe the Cabinet did not take the decision in accordance with the principles set out in Article 15 (Decision Making).
Reason for call in:
Principles of Decision Making –
Consideration of alternative options. The report presented to Cabinet did not set out alternative options or the option not to proceed. Cabinet did not therefore consider all options or viable alternatives. The report presented to Cabinet did not fully consider the risks involved. There was no detailed analysis of financial risk or otherwise. The report was not presented to Scrutiny or Audit in advance of the decision. I am therefore asking that Cabinet reconsider the decision, taking into account alternative options and a full risk analysis.
Advice from the Interim Monitoring Officer:
I have received a request for Call-In from Cllr Simon Clist as Chairman of Scrutiny Committee, thus meeting the threshold in rule 19(f) of the Scrutiny Committee etc. Procedure Rules.
The overarching rules of call-in must still be observed, namely:
1. Call-in by Scrutiny should only be used in exceptional circumstances. These are where members of Scrutiny Committee have evidence which suggests that the Cabinet did not take the decision in accordance with the principles set out in Article 15 (Decision-making) (rule 19 preamble);
2. Members who wish to call-in a decision are required to seek guidance from the Monitoring Officer on the veracity of their stated grounds for the call-in and demonstrate that they have been mindful of the advice they have received when deciding whether or not to proceed (rule 19 (f)); and
3. When the relevant Cabinet minutes are put before the Scrutiny Committee, together with the advice from the Monitoring Officer on the grounds for the call-in, the councillors who called in the decision shall have the right to attend and speak (rule 19 (h)). The principles of decision of decision-making – Article 15
Article 15.2 provides that all decisions of the Council will be made in accordance with the following principles:
a) Proportionality (i.e. the action must be proportionate to the desired outcome); b) Due consultation and the taking of professional advice from officers; c) Respect for human rights; d) A presumption in favour of openness; e) Clarity of aims and desired outcomes; f) Consideration of any alternative options; and g) The giving of reasons for the decision and the proper recording of those reasons
The above rules and principles apply. In this instance, from the reasons advanced, I can see that the first and primary reason put forward is that alternative options should have been considered (Article 15.2 (f)) i.e. the alternative option of not proceeding with the recommendation or viable alternatives. That is a principle of decision-making. As to whether the concern about alternative options for funding is an exceptional circumstance, I will leave that to the Committee. I would confirm that there is sufficient reason in accordance with the constitution for this decision to be called in.
There are other areas of concerns raised in the call-in that I will leave to be discussed by the Scrutiny Committee.
Discussion took place and consideration was given to:
That the papers had been published within the 5 day requirement and the supplement papers had been published as a matter of urgency.
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
2027/28 Draft Budget Update (00:04:00)RESOLVED that: 1. The proposed approach to balancing the 2027/28 General Fund and Housing Revenue Account budget gaps...
Minutes of the Previous MeetingThe minutes of the previous meeting held on 07 July 2026 were APPROVED as a correct record and SIGNED by the Leader. ...
2026/27 Budget Monitoring- Quarter 1The Cabinet had before it a report * from the Deputy Chief Executive (S151) on the 2025/26 Budgeting Monitoring quart...
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.