It was RESOLVED that: the Tree Preservation Order be confirmed. (Proposed by Cllr F Letch and seconded by Cllr F J Colthorpe) Reason for the Decision – as set out in the report. Notes:- *Report previously circulated copy attached to the minutes. (i) Jonathan Hall spoke as the Objector.
Word for word from the decision Mid Devon published for this meeting.Source: democracy.middevon.gov.uk
Location: Land at NGR 299306 102486 Strathculm Road Hele Devon
Proposal: Tree Preservation Order for 1 Copper Beech tree
Date Valid: 6th July 2023 TREE PRESERVATION ORDER: 23/00003/TPO
Site Visit: No
MEMBER CALL-IN:
Due to objection received from [name removed] the Tree Preservation Order 23/00003/TPO is confirmed.
Consultation carried out with: 1. The landowners have been notified of the imposition of the Tree Preservation Order and provided with the opportunity to object to its confirmation.
PROPOSAL:
Tree Preservation Order for 1 Copper Beech tree at Land at NGR 299306 102486 Strathculm Road, Hele
RELEVANT SITE HISTORY/DESCRIPTION:
OTHER HISTORY:
18/00569/PREAPP - CLO date DS,CLOSEDD.CNAPPLLOG,22; PROTECT - Restoration of building for use as community/heritage centre AMENITY EVALUATION:
The amenity evaluation has been reviewed 26/10/23 and adjusted accordingly. Original score 22. Reviewed score 20
1. Size Score Notes 1 Very small 2-5m ² 5 The tree is est. to be 10-12m in height with an est. crown 2 Small 5-10m ² spread of 8-10m. Tree is still growing and has the potential to become larger. 3 Small 10-25 ² 4 Medium 25-50m ² 5 Medium 50-100m ² 6 Large 100-200m ² 7 Very large 200m ² +
2. Life expectancy Score Notes 1 5-15 yrs 4 The tree is semi-mature (one-third life expectancy) 2 15-40 yrs estimated to be 30 years old. Typically beech can live for 3 40-100yrs over 150 years. 4 100yrs +
3. Form score Notes -1 Trees which are of poor 1 No obvious visual defects observed. Tree viewed to be of form typical form. Some included unions observed. 0 Trees of not very good form 1 Trees of average form 2 Trees of good form 3 Trees of especially good Form
4. Visibility Score Notes 0 Trees not visible to public 3 Trees is growing within a green space on the corner of 1 Trees only seen with Station road and Heal road and is very visible when difficulty or by a very small approached from both direction number of people 2 Back garden trees, or trees slightly blocked by other features 3 Prominent trees in well frequented places 4 Principal features in a public area.
5. Other trees in the area Score Notes 0.5 Wooded (70% = 100+ 1 Area viewed as semi-rural. Many trees within the garden trees) spaces, along field boundaries and surrounding green 1 Many (30% = 10+ trees) space. 2 Some (10% = 4+trees) 3 Few (<10% = 1+trees) 4 None
6. Suitability to area Score Notes -1 Unsuitable 3 Tree suitable for area that is characterised by broadleaf 1 Just suitable trees. Many of which are native. 2 Fairly suitable 3 Particularly suitable 4 Very suitable 7. Future amenity value Score Notes 0 Potential already 2 As the tree grows the visibility and prominence is likely to recognised increase where it could become a standout feature in the 1 Some potential local landscape providing further amenity value. 2 Medium potential 3 High potential
8. Tree influence On Score Notes Structures -1 Significant 0 Tree branches will require pruning to elevate conflict with 0 Slight overhead telecom lines. Low branches will require crown 1 Insignificant lifting over the highway periodically.
9. Added factors Score Notes 1 Rare 1 Tree was planted with by Hele Conservation Society and 1 Screening unpleasant view previously had a brass plate noting it’s planting in 1993. 1 Relevant to the Local Plan 1 Historical association 1 Considerable wildlife value 1 Veteran tree status If more than one factor relevant maximum score can still only be 2.
10. Notes and total score Score Notes Not / Reasonable for inclusion 20 The tree provides a level of amenity value that merits a within the TPO TPO. Tree is outside of a conservation area informing (>15 Merits consideration) there are no constraints restricting tree removal currently. Land where tree is growing has recently been sold informing tree could be threaten if land is developed.
REPRESENTATIONS:
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.