The award of this contract would realise a pressure of £78,314.08 against existing insurance premium and a £23,828.04 pressure against 2025/26 budget. This contract award protected the Council and its services from the financial risk of liability claims. Note * Report previously circulated
Word for word from the decision Mid Devon published for this meeting.Source: democracy.middevon.gov.uk
Cabinet Member: James Buczkowski – Cabinet Member for Governance, Finance & Risk
Responsible Officer: Andrew Jarrett – Deputy Chief Executive (S151)
Exempt: ANNEX A: PART II
Wards Affected: All
Enclosures: ANNEX A: PART II - Confidential
Section 1 – Summary and Recommendation(s) To advise Members on the results for the insurance contract tender for the whole Council from 1 April 2025 – 31 March 2028 (3 years) with the option to extend for a further 2 years and request approval to award of the contract.
Recommendation(s):
1. Cabinet is recommended to approve the new insurance contracts for the period 1 April 2025 – 31 March 2028 be awarded to:
Insurer 3 – Lot 1 – General Properties Insurer 3 – Lot 2 – Industrial and Commercial Property
Insurer 4 – Lot 3 – Casualty and Crime
Insurer 5 – Lot 4 – Motor Fleet
Insurer 4 – Lot 5 – Personal Accident and Travel
Insurer 4 – Lot 6 – Engineering Insurance and Inspection
Insurer 3 – Lot 7 – Leasehold Right to Buy Section 2 – Report
1. Introduction
1.1The expiry of the current long-term agreement on 31 March 2025 necessitated a Public tender for new insurance cover. Overall, the Tender has been a success for the following reasons:- Increased competition for the tender opportunity; A fully compliant procurement process; and Expanded range of risk management support now available on the key insurance risks
1.2AJ Gallaghers were appointed on 1 November 2024 via a direct award under YPO framework 001160 to support the Council in the tender for Insurance Services and on-going brokerage support. The role of AJ Gallaghers is to:
Provide advice and support throughout the tender process; Work closely with MDDC Insurance Officers to prepare the tender documents for each Lot stated above; Support MDDC Insurance Officers to answer tender clarification questions; Carry out the quality evaluations from Insurance tender bids received; and Produce an evaluation report to MDDC showing the scoring achieved for each tender submission in consultation with MDDC Insurance Officers.
2. Procurement Process
2.1The insurance tender documents were published on the Proactis portal on 19 December 2024 with the deadline of 3 February 2025 for completed submissions from interested insurance providers.
2.2The insurance portfolio was split into seven distinct Lots. Appropriate and bespoke Award Criteria were agreed and designed to ensure that Suppliers demonstrated within their bids how they were able to deliver the required level of cover and service.
2.3Each Lot has been evaluated on a standalone basis. The Evaluation is in terms of each bid meeting all aspects of the Award Criteria for that Lot. 2.4. The Criteria were structured along Price: Non-Price weighting percentages as detailed below. Standard Claims Range of Lot Price Specification Service Service Services % % % % % 1 General Property 40 25 5 15 15
2 Industrial and 40 25 25 10 Commercial 3 Casualty and Crime 40 25 5 15 15
4 Motor Fleet 60 15 5 15 5
5 Personal Accident and 60 15 5 15 5 Travel 6 Engineering Insurance 60 10 25 5 and Inspection 7 Leasehold Right to Buy 60 10 10 20
2.5Scoring Analysis for the Tenders received, and how the scoring under the Award Criteria was applied are shown below.
SCORING Insurer 1 Insurer 2 Insurer 3 Total Total Total Lot Quality Price Quality Price Quality Price Lot 1 41.00% 40.00% 81.00% Lot 2 41.00% 40.00% 81.00% Lot 3 41.00% 29.23% 70.23% 41.00% 30.81% 71.81% Lot 4 27.00% 53.45% 80.45% 27.00% 59.32% 86.32% Lot 5 30.00% 46.21% 76.21% Lot 6 37.00% 50.48% 87.48% Lot 7 26.00% 60.00% 86.00%
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
2027/28 Draft Budget Update (00:04:00)RESOLVED that: 1. The proposed approach to balancing the 2027/28 General Fund and Housing Revenue Account budget gaps...
Minutes of the Previous MeetingThe minutes of the previous meeting held on 07 July 2026 were APPROVED as a correct record and SIGNED by the Leader. ...
2026/27 Budget Monitoring- Quarter 1The Cabinet had before it a report * from the Deputy Chief Executive (S151) on the 2025/26 Budgeting Monitoring quart...
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.