CouncilMonitor
194 principal councils 228,996 meetings since 2000 2.8 million official papers archived Straight from each council's own publication system
Middlesbrough Borough Council
Place Scrutiny Panel, Tuesday 11 March 2025 at 4.30pm

Home to School Transport - Draft Final Report

Agreed Scrutiny 1 paper

Place Scrutiny Panel agreed this item on Tuesday 11 March 2025. Below is the council's own wording, with the papers it was decided on.

Item24/76

Resolved

AGREED as follows that: 1. The following recommendations were included in the Final Report: That Council should: · Investigate whether it would be cost effective to devolve the provision of Home to School Transport to individual schools, as they may be able to provide a more localised service. Ideally the funding could be passed directly to the schools making them responsible for controlling costs, ensuring there was no additional cost to the Local Authority. · Review the eligibility requirements for free school travel, especially for post-16 students and for pupils who attend a school that is not in the catchment/nearest school by parental choice, but they meet the low-income criteria. There would need to be an option included for consideration of special circumstances. · Ensure closer collaboration between Children’s Services, Schools and the Home to School Transport Unit to make certain that the most cost-effective and suitable transport arrangements are in place for each student, particularly in relation to students with SEND. The requirement for transport assistance should be included as a consideration in SEND assessments. · Prioritise the promotion of independent travel to all parents and students, increase the number of travel trainers and bus buddies and encourage greater use of personal travel budgets. · Introduce a spare seat scheme to offer discretionary transport assistance on existing transport for students who are not eligible for free travel assistance. · Investigate whether increasing the Council’s fleet of vehicles and reducing dependency on third party providers would be cost effective and whether this would enable better route planning. · Explore whether entering into longer-term contracts with third party providers would provide for greater flexibility and consistency. 2. an additional recommendation in relation to part payment would be drafted and added to the report. 3. a final version of the report would be circulated to all Panel Members with an opportunity for further amendments/comments, with final approval delegated to the Chair of the Panel. 4. the final report would be submitted to Overview and Scrutiny Board for consideration.
Word for word from the decision Middlesbrough published for this meeting. Source: moderngov.middlesbrough.gov.uk

Follow this further

Built from Middlesbrough's papers

What the report saysPro

Report to Place Scrutiny Panel

MIDDLESBROUGH COUNCIL

Final Report of the Place Scrutiny Panel

HOME TO SCHOOL TRANSPORT

CONTENTS

THE AIM OF THE SCRUTINY REVIEW Page 2

TERMS OF REFERENCE Page 2

BACKGROUND INFORMATION Page 2

SUMMARY OF EVIDENCE:

Term of Reference A - To establish the nature of the Home to School Transport Page 3 Service currently provided by Middlesbrough Council’s Integrated Transport Unit.

Term of Reference B – To examine the nature of the Home to School Transport Page 8 policy in light of the relevant statutory guidance.

Term of Reference C – To establish whether the present system is providing Page 10 adequate support for students travelling on school transport.

Term of Reference D – To identify the reasons for the increase in costs over time Page 11 and the implications for the overall funding on the service.

Term of Reference E – To investigate how other similar local authorities provide Page 12 this service and to identify ways in which the service could be improved and any costs minimised. ADDITIONAL INFORMATION Page 13

CONCLUSIONS Page 14

RECOMMENDATIONS Page 15

ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS Page 16

ACRONYMS Page 16

BACKGROUND PAPERS Page 16

APPENDIX A Page 18

APPENDIX B Page 19

APPENDIX C Page 20 THE AIM OF THE SCRUTINY REVIEW

1. The aim of the review is to ensure that the Council is meeting its obligations to provide Home to School Transport whilst effectively controlling costs.

2. The review also aims to assist the Local Authority (LA) in achieving the following priority from the Council Plan 2024-2027:

Delivering best value - Changing how we operate, to deliver affordable and cost-effective outcomes for residents and businesses.

TERMS OF REFERENCE

3. The terms of reference for the scrutiny panel’s review, are as follows:

A) To establish the nature of the Home to School Transport Service currently provided by Middlesbrough Council’s Integrated Transport Unit.

B) To examine the nature of the Home to School Transport policy in light of the relevant statutory guidance.

C) To establish whether the present system is providing adequate support for students travelling on school transport.

D) To identify the reasons for the increase in costs over time and the implications for the overall funding on the service.

E) To investigate how other similar local authorities provide this service and to identify ways in which the service could be improved and any costs minimized.

BACKGROUND INFORMATION

4. The legal requirement for ensuring that a child attends education is that of the parent or carer. However, it is the LA’s responsibility to provide travel assistance for all eligible children.

5. The ever-increasing need for the provision of home to school transport and travel assistance is a national issue. According to data obtained by the BBC and released in March 2024, costs of Special Educational Needs and Disability (SEND) school transport have increased nationally from £727m in 2019 to £1.4bn in 2024 and are predicted to rise further by 2027/28 to £2.2bn.

6. The County Councils Network (CCN) reported in November 2023 that growing costs were largely driven by an increase in pupils eligible for Education, Health and Care Plans (EHCPs), which has doubled from 240,000 in 2015 to 517,000 in 2023. 1 Other contributory factors to rises in demand and costs include: increasing complexity of children’s needs, lack of sufficient special school places, availability of drivers with D1 entitlement, availability of suppliers with vehicles in the private sector, economic climate, and supply and maintenance of the Council’s internal fleet.

1 https://www.countycouncilsnetwork.org.uk/councils-call-for-reform-of-send-school-transport-services.

2 7. National guidance issued by the Department for Education (DFE) sets out the expectations of Local Authorities regarding home to school travel and transport arrangements. In particular, the guidance sets out the circumstances in which the Local Authority has a duty to provide or arrange free school transport or travel support for children of compulsory school age.

Read every report as text, not just the decision

Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.

Papers for this item

Kept in our archive, download once signed in
PDF
Home to School Transport: Draft Final ReportReport 905 KB DownloadRead as text

At this meeting

Whole meeting

On this subject at Middlesbrough

Search all
  1. Home to School Transport - Draft Final ReportThis decision
  2. Final Report of the Place Scrutiny Panel – Home to School Transport ServiceApproved
  3. Home to School Transport Scrutiny Review - Update from Task and Finish GroupAgreed
  4. Home to School Transport Scrutiny Review - Update from Task and Finish Group and draft Terms of Reference for the reviewAgreed
  5. Home to School Transport Scrutiny Review - Terms of ReferenceAgreed

More from Middlesbrough Place Scrutiny Panel

All decisions
MeetingDecisionOutcome
27 Apr 2026 Minutes - Place Scrutiny Panel - 16 February 2026It was agreed that these would be incorporated, and the minutes were then approved. Agreed Open
27 Apr 2026 Minutes - Place Scrutiny Panel - 30 March 2026It was agreed that these would be incorporated, and the minutes were then approved. Agreed Open
27 Apr 2026 Section 106 Agreements - Verbal UpdateAGREED that: 1. The information provided was received and noted. 2. Guidance would be shared with all Councillors aro... Agreed Open
27 Apr 2026 Overview and Scrutiny Board UpdateAGREED that the information provided was received and noted. Agreed Open
16 Feb 2026 Annual Update - RIPA (Regulation of Investigatory Powers)It was agreed with the IPCO following their last inspection in 2020 that we continued to maintain an overarching Surv... Agreed Open

We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies