CouncilMonitor
194 principal councils 228,996 meetings since 2000 2.8 million official papers archived Straight from each council's own publication system
Monmouthshire County Council
Cabinet, Wednesday 11 January 2017 at 2.00pm

Recommendations and Outcomes from Select Committees

Decided Executive 1 paper

Cabinet decided this item on Wednesday 11 January 2017. Below is the council's own wording, with the papers it was decided on.

Item3

Resolved

That the Cabinet acknowledge the contribution made by the Council’s Select Committees towards policy development and decision-making. That Cabinet Members familiarise themselves with the outcomes of the Select Committees to ensure they respond appropriately to recommendations and requests made by the Select Committees, in line with the Council’s Scrutiny and Executive Protocol
Word for word from the decision Monmouthshire published for this meeting. Source: democracy.monmouthshire.gov.uk

Follow this further

Built from Monmouthshire's papers

What the report saysPro

Report to Cabinet

Recommendations

i) That the Cabinet acknowledge the contribution made by the Council’s Select Committees towards policy development and decision-making;

ii) That Cabinet Members familiarise themselves with the outcomes of the Select Committees to ensure they respond appropriately to recommendations and requests made by the Select Committees, in line with the Council’s Scrutiny and Executive Protocol.

3. KEY ISSUES:

3.1Select Committees conduct a variety of important ‘critical friend’ roles:

i) Reviewing the appropriateness of existing policy and shaping new policy to ensure ‘fitness for purpose’;

ii) Conducting pre-decision scrutiny, by challenging the rationale for proposed decisions with the decision-maker;

iii) Holding the Cabinet Members and Officers to account for their performance, including their management of budgets and risks;

iv) Engaging with the public to ensure that the Council is delivering effective services which resonate with needs of the public, their communities and local businesses.

3.2The Select Committees add value by driving improvement in service delivery and through offering constructive challenge to decision makers to ensure decisions are robust. Each Select Committee agrees its forward work programme and undertakes its workload in a flexible manner to ensure diligent scrutiny of key emerging programmes, projects and initiatives. This has led to an increased number of additional Select Committees being called to scrutinise single subjects, sometimes on a recurring basis. The calling of additional meetings is an approach that is favoured over the establishment of numerous task and finish groups, given the ability for Scrutiny Members to produce quicker outcomes in addition to enabling wider elected Member and public involvement in its meetings.

3.3In line with the Council’s Scrutiny and Executive Protocol, Cabinet Members are invited to Select Committees to be challenged upon their performance and also their rationale for decisions they may make. Outcomes of Select Committees are formally recorded in the minutes of Select Committees following ‘summing up’ by the Select Committee Chair, who will (if appropriate) write to the relevant Cabinet Member or Chief Officer to advise the Committee’s stance on an issue together with any recommendation the Select Committee wishes to make. Discussions are frequently held between the Select Committee Chairs and the relevant Cabinet Member following the meeting, with further scrutiny and requests for information identified.

3.3Following a self-evaluation of the scrutiny function in 2014 and a corporate assessment in 2015, the Scrutiny Chairs agreed a need to formally document outcomes and recommendations made by Select Committees via a regular report to the Council’s Cabinet. The purpose of the report is to demonstrate the valuable contribution made by Scrutiny Members and to ensure that Cabinet Members are aware of the outcomes of Select Committees, in order that they may respond appropriately.

4. REASONS:

4.1To implement effective corporate governance and decision-making, through ensuring clarity of role, purpose and mutual expectations of the Select Committees and the Cabinet.

5. RESOURCE IMPLICATIONS:

None identified.

6. SUSTAINABLE DEVELOPMENT AND EQUALITY IMPLICATIONS:

None identified.

7. SAFEGUARDING AND CORPORATE PARENTING IMPLICATIONS

None identified.

8. CONSULTEES:

Not required.

Background papers

None - Minutes publicly available.

10. AUTHOR:

Hazel Ilett, Scrutiny Manager

11. CONTACT DETAILS:

Tel: 01633 644233 E-mail: [email protected] Record of Recommendations/Outcomes from Select Committees during September and December 2016 (16 meetings)

Read every report as text, not just the decision

Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.

Papers for this item

Kept in our archive, download once signed in
PDF
Recommendations and Outcomes from Select CommitteesReport 363 KB DownloadRead as text

At this meeting

Whole meeting

Who was there

5 of 27 attended
CC
County Councillor Geoff BurrowsCommittee Member, present
CC
County Councillor Peter FoxCommittee Member, present
CC
County Councillor Bob GreenlandCommittee Member, present
CC
County Councillor Liz Hacket PainCommittee Member, apologies
CC
County Councillor Phyl HobsonCommittee Member, present
CC
County Councillor Bryan JonesCommittee Member, apologies
CC
County Councillor Phil MurphyCommittee Member, present
BB
Bridgit BarnettOfficer, expected
KB
Kellie BeirneOfficer, expected
AB
Alan BurkittOfficer, expected
PD
Peter DaviesOfficer, in attendance
TH
Tracey HarryOfficer, expected

All 27 on the meeting page

On this subject at Monmouthshire

Search all
  1. Recommendations and Outcomes from Select CommitteesThis decision
  2. Recommendations and outcomes from Select Committee'sDecided

More from Monmouthshire Cabinet

All decisions
MeetingDecisionOutcome
11 Nov 2026 Local Growth Fund Year 2 and 3 2027- 2029That the Cabinet considered the draft Local Growth Fund proposals for Years 2 and 3. That Cabinet approves the portfo... Approved Open
11 Nov 2026 Future of Former Tudor Street Day Centre, AbergavennyTo terminate the existing Tenancy at Will agreement with The Gathering Community CIO. To Approve the commencement of ... Agreed Open
11 Nov 2026 Medium Term Financial Plan Update - October 2026That Cabinet notes the refreshed MTFP update at Appendix 1, including the current scenario based planning range for 2... Decided Open
14 Oct 2026 Performance and Overview Scrutiny Committee - Feedback to Cabinet of Meeting held on 29th September 2026Noted. Noted Open
14 Oct 2026 Place Committee - Feedback to Cabinet of Meeting held on 1st October 2026Noted. Noted Open

We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies