Report of the Overview and Scrutiny Committee and Health Scrutiny Committee: A clean, green, and inclusive city for all: our medium-term financial planning for 2022-23 to 2024-25
AgreedExecutive3 papers
Cabinet agreed this item on Monday 21 February 2022. Below is the council's own wording, with the papers it was decided on.
Cabinet agreed to: i. Consider the comments and concerns of scrutiny on the council’s budget proposals and take them into account in finalising the budget recommendations to be submitted to City Council. ii. Note that scrutiny will maintain a degree of oversight of the budget process as well as continuing to monitor and review implementation and impact of budget proposals during the coming municipal year, which may also include a review of responses received to the budget consultation from the public and stakeholders and budget changes that had been made as a result.
Word for word from the decision Newcastle published for this meeting.Source: democracy.newcastle.gov.uk
Scrutiny Q&A – Medium-Term Financial Plan for 2022-2025
A clean, green and inclusive city for all – Our medium-term financial planning for 2022-23 to 2023-24
"We are facing a gap of approximately £36 million over 2022-23 to 2024-25, with £12 million of service savings required each year." How approximate this is – what is the potential variance?
This is the latest estimate based on assumptions in relation to Council Tax and business rates growth, funding from government, inflationary cost increases, annual pay awards agreed, increases in the National Living Wage, rates agreed with care home providers, population changes, changes in demand for services etc. and will need to be kept under review over the next two years. Budget estimates made by officers over the last few years have been very close to the outturn position seen by the council which shows that the assumptions made were fairly accurate. There are a number of things that could change up to the point the budget is considered by City Council in March 2022, but it’s unlikely that the bottom line will vary significantly Officers are more confident in relation to the following financial year than for years two and three because of the number of variables which could play into the process in that time such as changes in government policy, changes in government support, increases or reductions in income, the pay award and the accuracy of OBR inflation figures.
What proportion of each of the revenue and capital budgets are dedicated to the net zero plan? What in the budget can be identified as going towards achieving net zero?
Carbon reduction efforts are primarily funded through capital investment and the amount of investment can vary year on year as it is often funded through time-bound grants. In recent years, we have increased our core revenue allocation to support climate change, increasing our capacity dedicated to delivering our Net Zero Newcastle: 2030 Action Plan. The profile of capital and dedicated revenue allocation since 2018-19 is: 2018-19: £7.3 million 2019-20: £21.4 million 2020-21: 5.7 million 2021-22: £40.0 million We are unable to breakdown the specific elements of capital projects and spend targeted at climate change, for example, spend on electric vehicles is accounted for but we may have already been planning to replace these vehicles. This spend profile does not reflect the wider cross-council work and activity to tackle climate change through day to day service delivery, again, it would be difficult to specify which elements of those revenue budgets were purely for climate change activity.
With regards to the example of spend on electric vehicles given above, does this mean that the council may have been planning to purchase those vehicles anyway, regardless of Net Zero? To what extent has the profile of capital expenditure changed since the implementation of Net Zero?
The cost of replacing old vehicles with electric ones has been given as an example of spend within the capital programme targeted at climate change as although it may have been necessary to replace those vehicles at a certain point in time anyway, moving to electric vehicles will be more expensive. This is particularly true for larger vehicles such as refuse collection vehicles because of their size and scale and there not being an advanced market for those types of electric vehicles. So the council might spend more on that type of vehicle than it would have done if it was being purchased just for its primary purpose. If the council was not following a Net Zero agenda it could be argued that the capital programme would be lower to the tune of the schemes identified in the written response, particularly where they were schemes where the council had successfully bid for funding for that specific purpose.
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
Report of the Overview and Scrutiny Committee and Health Scrutiny Committee: A clean, green, and inclusive city for all: our medium-term financial planning for 2022-23 to 2024-25:Report
3Report of the Overview and Scrutiny Committee and Health Scrutiny Committee: A clean, green, and inclusive city for all: our medium-term financial planning for 2022-23 to 2024-25This decision
Report of the Overview and Scrutiny Committee and Health Scrutiny Committee: A clean, green, and inclusive city for all: our medium-term financial planning for 2022-23 to 2024-25This decision
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.