Decision Agreed, subject to any comments from the Standards Committee, that the following be added to the Protocol for the Development Committee on planning matters: Avoidance of Bias 3.7 Members should bring an open mind to an application and give impartial consideration to all relevant planning issues. If a Member has already taken a firm public position on a matter this would give the impression that they might not bring an open mind to the issue at committee. In these circumstances the Member would not necessarily have a personal interest in the matter but should not participate in the consideration of the matter because an informed observer would be likely to conclude that the Member had approached the decision with a closed mind. Membership of a lobby or campaign group Lobbying and Membership of a lobby or campaign group A member who is a member of a lobby or campaign group should carefully consider whether they can participate in a planning application where the group has campaigned for or against a particular proposal. Advice from the Standards Board for England is that a “particularly cautious approach should be adopted to planning (and licensing) matters. You should avoid committing yourself on any matter that may fall to be decided by you as a member of a planning (or licensing) committee”. A member should consider the nature of their involvement with the group; the publicly expressed views of the lobby or campaigning group; what has been said or done in relation to the particular group and consider whether a member of the public with all the facts would reasonably think that the interest is significant, that your decision on the matter would be prejudicial by it. If the answer is yes than you must declare a personal and prejudicial interest and leave the room.
Word for word from the decision Newham published for this meeting.Source: mgov.newham.gov.uk
To consider and comment on proposed amendments to the Protocol for the Development Control Committee on Planning matters.
Recommendations – Development Control Committee
Development Control Committee is asked to note the proposed changes to the protocol and to comment on the proposed changes.
Standards Committee
Standards Committee is asked to note and comment as they wish on the proposed changes to the protocol.
1 Report
Background
On the 10th November 2004 Members of the former Development Control and Licensing Committee and on the 29th November 2004 Members of the Standards Committee considered proposed revisions to the Protocol on planning matters for the Development Control and Licensing Committee. Since then Members have received a letter from the Head of Legal Services and guidance from the Standards Board for England on “Lobby Groups, dual-hatted members and the Code of Conduct”.
In order to take account of the guidance from the Standards Board for England some further changes and clarifications are recommended to the Protocol. Under Article 15.02 (b) of the Councils Constitution, the monitoring officer, may make changes to part 5 of the Constitution which consists of codes and protocols.
Appearance of Bias
Members should bring an open mind when determining a planning application and give impartial consideration to all relevant planning issues.
1. The test of bias is whether a fair – minded and informed observer with knowledge of all the relevant facts would conclude that there was a real possibility of bias because a decision is being approached with closed minds and without impartial consideration.
2. If a member has already taken a firm public view on a matter he or she should not participate in the determination of the application. In these circumstances it is possible that the Member will not have a personal interest but should not participate because to do so would give an appearance that the Member concerned was biased.
3. To clarify this point it is proposed that the following be included in the Protocol.
Avoidance of Bias
3.7Members should bring an open mind to an application and give impartial consideration to all relevant planning issues.
If a Member has already taken a firm public position on a matter this would give the impression that they might not bring an open mind to the issue at committee.
In these circumstances the Member would not necessarily have a personal interest in the matter but should not participate in the consideration of the matter because an informed observer would be likely to conclude that the Member had approached the decision with a closed mind.
Membership of a lobby or campaign group
The present protocol refers to lobbying but does not make explicit reference to Members who are Members of a lobby or campaigning group.
In view of the Standards Board for England advice on lobby groups it is recommended that the following be included in the protocol.
2 Lobbying and Membership of a lobby or campaign group
A member who is a member of a lobby or campaign group should carefully consider whether they can participate in a planning application where the group has campaigned for or against a particular proposal. Advice from the Standards Board for England is that a “particularly cautious approach should be adopted to planning (and licensing) matters. You should avoid committing yourself on any matter that may fall to be decided by you as a member of a planning (or licensing) committee”.
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.