CouncilMonitor
194 principal councils 228,996 meetings since 2000 2.8 million official papers archived Straight from each council's own publication system
London Borough of Newham
SACRE, Thursday 10 March 2005

Determinations

Agreed Committee 4 papers

SACRE agreed this item on Thursday 10 March 2005. Below is the council's own wording, with the papers it was decided on.

Item6

Resolved

Decision Each Panel separated to consider their vote, which was recorded as follows: LEA Panel In Favour C of C Panel In Favour Other Faiths Panel In Favour Teachers Panel In Favour Agreed to grant that application for renewal of their existing determinations to St Stephen’s Primary School. (b) Selwyn Primary School SACRE received a presentation from Keith Moore-Brown, RE Advisor at Selwyn Primary School on the provision of religious education and collective worship at Selwyn Primary school in support of their application for determination. A copy of the school’s Assembly rotas for 2004/5 Academic year, along with evidence of consultation with the governing body, parents and staff, were submitted for consideration. Decision Each Panel separated to consider their vote, which was recorded as follows: LEA Panel In Favour C of C Panel In Favour Other Faiths Panel In Favour Teachers Panel In Favour Agreed to grant that application for determination to Selwyn Primary School . (b) Monega Primary School As no representative from the school was present for the meeting, SACRE agreed to defer consideration. Decision Agreed to defer considered of this application to our next meeting to allow for representation from Monega Primary School .
Word for word from the decision Newham published for this meeting. Source: mgov.newham.gov.uk

Follow this further

Built from Newham's papers

What the report saysPro

Report to SACRE

Appendix Seven Appendix A

Pro-forma to be completed by Head Teacher and sent with supporting documentation to: The Committee Section, Newham Town Hall, East Ham, London. E6 2RP

APPLICATION TO SACRE FOR A DETERMINATION

1. DETAILS ABOUT SCHOOL

1.1Name of school: Monega Primary School

1.2Type of school (please tick appropriate boxes):

Special Infant Junior Primary √

Sec., 11-16 Sec., 11-18 Community √ Foundation

1.3Number of pupils on roll: 667

2. REASONS FOR SEEKING A DETERMINATION

2.1Family religious background:

RELIGION NO. OF PUPILS % PUPILS Buddhist Christian 40 Hindu 45 Jewish Muslim 512 Sikh 39 None 4 Not known 2 Others 25 (specify if known)

2.2(a) Current number of pupils who are withdrawn: 2

Other than this there have over the past fifteen years been no withdrawals from assemblies

Family religious background of pupils who are withdrawn:

Muslim

(c) Current provision for pupils who are withdrawn:

Parents have indicated that they do not want alternative provision as they wish to take full responsibility for their children’s religious development.

1 2.3 (a) Determination being sought for whole school (please tick appropriate box) √ Determination being sought for part of school

(b) If 'part' actual number of pupils for whom alternative worship is being sought:…………….. If 'part', % pupils for whom alternative worship is being sought:…………………….. Does this group include those pupils referred to in DETAILS MUST BE SUBMITTED.

2.4Reasons for applying for a determination, including an explanation of why collective worship that is wholly or mainly of a broadly Christian character is inappropriate in respect of the family backgrounds of the pupils for whom alternative worship is being sought

As the table shows the school population is comprised of pupils from a variety of faiths and the largest faith group within school is Muslim. Prior to the introduction of determination the school experienced a number of difficulties with parents who wished to withdraw their children from assemblies on the grounds that they were not representative of their child’s religious background. The school has applied for and been granted a determination since its first inception and this has allowed for a daily act of worship to take place which meets the needs of the communities represented in school. It also offers the opportunity for a wider understanding of the culture, heritage and beliefs of others and to demonstrate the importance of having a faith. In turn this has led to the formation of a harmonious school community where pupils are willing to share their faith and respect those of others.

3 EVIDENCE OF CONSULTATION

3.1People consulted (please tick appropriate boxes):

Governing body √ Teachers √ Parents

Faith communities Pupils √ Others

3.2Details of the consultation process: DETAILS MUST BE SUBMITTED

Consultation with governing body

After careful consideration of the religious background of the pupils attending Monega Primary School the governors strongly feel that Collective Acts of Worship of a broadly Christian nature would be wholly inappropriate and fully support the application for determination. In addition they have discussed the evidence now presented, together with the provisional pattern and content of assemblies for next term and have given their full support.

Consultation with staff

The whole staff has discussed the requirements for determination and they have reached a consensus view that a determination should be applied for and that they would support the pattern of themes and organisation of assemblies proposed.

2 All staff have further indicated that they would be willing to lead such assemblies though some have indicated that they would not wish to lead prayers but would rather offer a reflective thought, idea or short reading for meditation.

Consultation with parents

Read every report as text, not just the decision

Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.

Papers for this item

Kept in our archive, download once signed in
PDF
Determination 05Report 32 KB DownloadRead as text
PDF
DeterminationsReport 1.6 MB Download
PDF
SelwynReport 2.2 MB Download
PDF
consultReport 67 KB Download

At this meeting

Whole meeting

Who was there

15 of 24 attended
QP
Councillor Quintin PeppiattChair, present
EK
Ellen KempDeputy Chair, present
SA
Councillor Shama Ahmad MBEMember, apologies
AI
Asela Ibrahim-ElMorsyMember, present
CA
Chris AubreyMember, present
PB
Dr. Parish BhasiMember, absent
JB
Jude BullockMember, absent
AC
Councillor Ayesha ChowdhuryMember, apologies due to council business
JC
Jill CroxfordMember, absent
RD
Rev. Dr. Jane FreemanMember, present
CP
Canon Peter HartleyMember, present
SH
S HusainMember, present

All 24 on the meeting page

On this subject at Newham

Search all
  1. DeterminationsThis decision
  2. Register of Determinations UpdateDecided
  3. Determinations for Collective Worship - Principles and GuidelinesAgreed

More from Newham SACRE

All decisions
MeetingDecisionOutcome
4 Feb 2026 Agreed Syllabus Conference (ASC) - Meeting 1Agreed Syllabus Conference (ASC) - Meeting 1 Following closure of the SACRE meeting, the ASC formally opened at 19:40... Agreed Open
3 Feb 2021 Management of Business and Appointment of New MembersRESOLVED that the Alexia Charalambous be appointed to the role. Decided Open
3 Feb 2021 Student SACRE ReportRESOLVED to note the update. Noted Open
3 Feb 2021 SACRE Annual ReportRESOLVED to note the report and information provided. Noted Open
3 Feb 2021 Agreed Syllabus - Text and Process: What Next?RESOLVED to note the discussion and request for engagement. Action Requests arising out of the report were: C Martin ... Noted Open

We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies