Decision Agreed that the following approach be adopted at the Public Inquiry: Refusal of permission is supported in respect of the “2002” scheme because of the failure to make any provision for a safeguarded wharf activity (P/04/0847); and Permission should be granted subject to a planning agreement for the other scheme (P/04/0570) which provides an aggregate facility as this accords with the Council’s regeneration aspirations and that retention of all of the safeguarded wharf area with the addition of a refuse recycling plant would be to the detriment of those aspirations. Furthermore provision of aggregates and refuse recycling would also have a detrimental impact on the type and quality of uses that could be provided on nearby sites.
Word for word from the decision Newham published for this meeting.Source: mgov.newham.gov.uk
Two planning applications were submitted last year with Environmental Statements relating to the site of Peruvian Wharf, North Woolwich Road E16. Both applications (Refs. P/04/0570 and 0847) are for high density, high quality mixed use development but one (P/04/0570) includes an aggregate facility fronting onto the Thames. The front part of the Wharf is a safeguarded wharf, which means that area should be occupied by uses which depend on the Thames for bringing cargo to and/or from the site.
The application which provides various commercial uses plus residential, open space and a riverside walkway and no uses related to the safeguarded wharf (P/04/0847) was originally submitted in 2002 and considered by the Committee in February 2003. Members were minded to grant permission subject to a planning agreement and referral to the GLA. The Secretary of State then directed that the application should have been accompanied by an Environmental Statement and was therefore invalid. Both schemes need to be referred to the GLA who have already indicated that they are minded to refuse the applications because of the failure to comply with the Safeguarded Wharf provision – the aggregate facility is on a reduced and amended area compared with what is safeguarded.
At the start of February 2005 duplicate applications were submitted and appeals submitted to the Planning Inspectorate against non determination of the applications submitted in 2004. A Public Inquiry is to be held into the appeals. Whilst the date of the Inquiry is not yet known officers have to submit a Statement of Case, which sets out the main points to be made on behalf of the Council, by 11th April 2005. Whilst the applications have not been formally considered by Members, given this is a significant case with implications for the Council’s regeneration aspirations and vision for the future of the Borough, it is considered important to bring the main issues before Members and obtain agreement as to the approach to be taken at the Inquiry. These are set out in the attached first draft of the Statement of Case. This will obviously be amended following advice from the Council’s solicitor and counsel. However the main points of issue are set out in the draft statement and Members agreement is sought to the approach.
The approach to the two applications can be summarised as –
1. The “2002” scheme (P/04/0847). Whilst originally Members supported the scheme this was at a time when the designation of safeguarded wharves was being reviewed and the London Plan was in draft form. Representations had been made by the Council on both documents that there were too many safeguarded wharves in the Borough which had a detrimental impact on regeneration and that three non operational wharves, including Peruvian, should no longer be designated. Despite these representations Peruvian Wharf has been confirmed as a safeguarded wharf, following the publication by the GLA of the review which has also been agreed by the ODPM, and the London Plan which includes related policies and statements about wharves is now adopted.
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.