The Mayor in consultation with Cabinet agreed: 1. to note the actions taken to respond to the investigation report and the decision of the Audit Board to agree the overall response and proposed changes with regards to prevention and detection of any similar circumstances arising across the Council’s services; and 2. that Cabinet receives regular six-monthly health check reports around the areas of Human Resources, Service and Finance. Reasons for the decision The reporting of a suite of organisational health factors will help to identify any areas where there may be issues requiring some form of intervention at an early stage. The report and decision have complied with Part 4.5, paragraph 16 of the Constitution. The decision is not subject to the call in process and may be implemented immediately
Word for word from the decision Newham published for this meeting.Source: mgov.newham.gov.uk
1. Following a number of allegations made in an anonymous letter I asked the Council’s internal audit section to undertake preliminary investigations into the Housing Needs Service. After receiving the initial findings I concluded that there was sufficient concern that a full investigation should be conducted.
2. The Council has a strong reputation in dealing with such matters robustly transparently and effectively and in implementing remedial action to rectify any shortcomings speedily.
3. I decided therefore to commission an external independent investigation and Amanda Kelly was appointed to carry this out and she worked closely with the Council’s internal audit service in completing the task.
Investigation Report
4. Amanda Kelly’s report of her investigations and her conclusions and recommendations is attached.
5. During the investigation a number of aspects that have been highlighted have required immediate action and a number of changes and different contractual arrangements have already been implemented.
6. The detailed findings are set out in the report but the main thrust of the conclusions of the investigation can be summarised as:-
• No evidence of corrupt relationships between officers and external agents
• A complex area of activity with significant pressure to deal with Government Targets ( including challenging statutory Bed and Breakfast targets ) and changes in Housing Benefit rules that has expanded significantly with substantial workloads
• High turnover in management resource and use of agency staff
• A service that was perceived to be delivering outcomes and improving performance
• Lack of competence and understanding of core processes
• Lack of importance given to procurement and basic financial processes and systems Leading to;-
• Clear serious breaches of the Councils procurement code of practice
• Poor administration and documentation
• Preferential treatment given to certain lettings agencies
• Lack of control and poor value for money
• High risk of loss and fraud to the Council
• High risk of perception of corruption
Response to the findings
7. During the investigation a number of actions were considered and have already been implemented. Essentially the response to date can be considered over four key aspects;-
• Management of the service
A new acting Head of Housing and Public Protection is overseeing the Service and the implementation of the recovery plan
• Specific Contracts and use of external lettings agencies
The acting Head of Housing and Public Protection, Head of Legal services and Head of Finance are working together to regularise the contractual position. Likewise the Council is taking the opportunity to reconsider its needs especially in light of the growing source of accommodation provided through Local Space. . Notices have been served for the termination of contracts for procurement and management and maintenance of temporary accommodation. Notice has also been served for the termination of the contract for Bed and Breakfast provision. Furthermore, the usage of one particular maintenance company has been ended with immediate effect and investigations into works undertaken is ongoing and may result in further action.. Preparations have commenced for the re-procurement of all these services.
• Compliance with Codes of practice and basic processes and rules
The procurement, Financial and HR processes and procedures have been reinforced ♦ Awareness of and availability of Procurement Training has been increased and this will be further improved through the controls set out in the recommendations
♦ The Procurement Code will be reviewed to pick up the recommendations on conflicts of interest
♦ Those undertaking procurement activities will have to have been trained.
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.