Decision The Mayor agreed to: 1. Note the findings of the Project Centre report; 2. Approve an extension of the Construction Services and Responsive Services contracts until 30 September 2014, subject to the Executive Member for Finance, Property and Support Services, being fully briefed on the profitability of the contractor, and being satisfied that the contract is value for money; and 3. Authorise the Director Environmental Services to deal with and agree any other issues that may arise where such are in the interests of the Council. Reasons for the Decision To enable the Council to discharge its highway maintenance obligations arising from the Highways Act 1980 and to deliver highway improvement and renewal schemes in a cost effective, timely and quality controlled manner. This decision is subject to the call-in process as the decision was based on part exempt information. The call-in period will expire at 5pm on 18 February 2012.
Word for word from the decision Newham published for this meeting.Source: mgov.newham.gov.uk
1.1At the 17 February 2011 Mayoral Proceedings, the Mayor considered a report about a proposed extension of highways contracts. The Mayor did not approve an extension of the Construction Services and Responsive Services contracts until October 2014 and requested the Strategic Procurement Unit to lead a review of both contracts. The Mayor agreed to hire additional technical support to undertake this work if required.
1.2In making his decision, the Mayor was concerned about value for money, Member perceptions about the quality of work and an apparent lack of alternative options.
1.3Strategic Procurement Unit drew up a list of tenderers. Tenders were invited via the Council’s electronic tendering system, NECTR. Following evaluation and a series of clarification meetings, Project Centre was appointed to review the Construction Services and Responsive Services contracts.
1.4Project Centre commenced the review in May 2011 and submitted the final version of its report in September 2011. This review cost approximately £20,000 and validates the original officer recommendations.
1.5The review involved a series of meetings with the Mayor, the Executive Member for Infrastructure and Environment, the Council’s highways team, incumbent contractor FM Conway Ltd, Ringway Jacobs and Volker Highways. These meetings gleaned information to understand the current delivery mechanisms for highway services and to validate options for the future of the contracts under review.
1.6Financial benchmarking was undertaken to check whether the Construction Services and Responsive Services contracts still provide value for money. This involved pricing completed projects at High Street South and Monmouth Road using rates from the Ringway Jacobs Contract and from four other London Boroughs. This exercise confirmed that FM Conway Ltd’s rates are similar to those in other boroughs and provides sufficient insight to suggest that a full tender exercise would not necessarily provide a cheaper outcome, and could be more expensive.
1.7Project Centre visited four sites to check the quality of FM Conway Ltd’s work. These included completed sites at High Street South, Monmouth Road and Little Ilford and a live site at East Ham High Street. In all cases, the quality of work was found to be of an acceptable standard. The live site was very active and appropriate measures were in place to safeguard the public and the contractor’s operatives and maintain access to affected properties. 1.8 A report on Project Centre’s findings was considered at the 3 November 2011 Mayoral Proceedings. As a result of a Mayoral request, the report is now re-submitted with additional information about profit margins.
1.9It is essential that contractors working for the Council are able to make a fair margin to ensure they continue delivering services and employ local residents. If margins are squeezed too far, there is a risk that some contractors would submit more claims or go out of business. In that scenario, the Council would end up paying more for services and local jobs would be put at risk.
1.10The Construction Services and Responsive Services contracts were awarded to FM Conway Ltd as the contractor with the most economically advantageous tender. Since their rates are lower than those of other tenderers, the margin is academic.
2. Key Considerations and Sustainability
2.1The Project Centre report recommends extending the Construction Services and Responsive Services contracts until July 2014 and taking the following actions to improve value for money:
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.