Decision The Mayor in consultation with Cabinet agreed to clarify that: 1. The recommendations agreed on 17 November do not exclude the possibility of future face to face advice services being provided by independent organisations within Tier 3 of the IAG model presently being worked up; 2. The extent of the face to face advice services in Tier 3, including the identity of those providing the advice and the eligibility criteria applied to those seeking the advice, will be the subject of formal consultation carried out; 3. The consultation, conducted in accordance with the Council’s public sector equalities duties, will inform the development of Tier 3 of the IAG model; and 4. Officers will report back to the Mayor in consultation with Cabinet before Tier 3 of the IAG model be formally considered for adoption/implementation. Reasons for the Decision At the time of the November 2011 report, the development of Tier 3 of the IAG model was at a nascent stage; the recommendation was not intended to formally adopt Tier 3 but seek approval for its development. The legal challenge to the decision is based on an assertion that the recommendations contained an express determination that the model for future advice services would be provided by Council officers and would not include any provision from any external organisation. There was no such express recommendation and the recommendations above are intended to clarify ... view the full minutes text for item 7.
Word for word from the decision Newham published for this meeting.Source: mgov.newham.gov.uk
The purpose of this report is to inform the Mayor and Cabinet that a legal challenge has been issued impunging the decision made by the Mayor in consulation with Cabinet on 17 November 2011 to agree the recommendations set out in the report on the Information Advice and Guidance project (Agenda Item 7 of that day’s meeting).
Officers believe the challenge is based on a mis-reading of the agreed recommendations and invite the Mayor, in consultation with Cabinet to agree the recommendations set out below. The objective is to clarify the effect of the recommendations agreed on 17 November and confirm the Council’s intention to comply with its obligations under S149 of the Equalities Act 2010 and other statutory requirements regarding consultation, in the development of Tier 3 of the Information Advice and Guidance project.
The legal challenge argues that the 17 November decision had the effect of determining the model for future advice services in circumstances where the Council had not complied with its public sector equalities duties and the obligation to consult. This is a mis-understanding of the recommendations and overlooks certain explanations and commitments set out in the report. Specifically, at paragraph 2.9 the report explained that once it was determined which services would be included in Tier 3, Equality Impact Assessments could be carried out in respect of each. Paragraph 7.1 re-affirmed this by stating that any advisable consultation would be carried out. The purpose of this report, for the avoidance of any doubt, is to make clear what was meant by the report of 17 November and the intended effect of the agreed recommendations.
Reason for Urgency
Not Applicable
Reason for Lateness
Not Applicable
Recommendations
The Mayor in consultation with Cabinet is asked to clarify that:
1. The recommendations agreed on 17 November do not exclude the possibility of future face to face advice services being provided by independent organisations within Tier 3 of the IAG model presently being worked up. 2. The extent of the face to face advice services in Tier 3, including the identity of those providing the advice and the eligibility criteria applied to those seeking the advice, will be the subject of formal consultation carried out. 3. The consultation, conducted in accordance with the Council’s public sector equalities duties, will inform the development of Tier 3 of the IAG model. 4. Officers will report back to the Mayor in consultation with Cabinet before Tier 3 of the IAG model be formally considered for adoption/implementation.
Reasons for the recommendations
At the time of the November 2011 report, the development of Tier 3 of the IAG model was at a nascent stage; the recommendation was not intended to formally adopt Tier 3 but seek approval for its development. The legal challenge to the decision is based on an assertion that the recommendations contained an express determination that the model for future advice services would be provided by Council officers and would not include any provision from any external organisation.
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.