Resolved
Decision Maker: The Chief Executive in consultation with the Director of Finance, Director of Legal and Governance the Mayor, Deputy Mayor and Cabinet Member for Financial Inclusion and Health Promotion. Decision The Chief Executive agreed the proposed loan to LCCU on the terms set out in Appendix 1. Reason for the Decision NewCred is the primary credit union currently operating in the borough and the only one of the three credit unions whose ‘common bond’ to operate covers the borough to have a physical presence in Newham. NewCred was initially supported by the Council but has been independent since 2010 and receives no funding. In July 2014 the Chairman of NewCred’s Board of Trustees wrote to Newham to seek an unsubordinated loan of £155,000 over 10 years in order to meet its regulatory responsibilities which it was in breach of. Without support from Newham or another organisation NewCred would have to cease trading. The need for the loan had occurred because NewCred was not meeting the capital to asset ratio required by the PRA. The Council took the view that it was not able to provide financial assistance to NewCred under the current management and informed NewCred promptly of this. The primary reasons were that the Council was not confident that the current management could put in place a business plan to ensure the loan was repaid at term. The identification of accounting errors, the relatively weak product offer NewCred has compared to other credit unions and the declining value of the organisation’s loan book, which fell 10.6% between 2012 and 2013, were all factors. In addition NewCred introduced additional charges for customers as a revenue generating stream, which the Council does not believe is a long term solution. The Council was however keen to ensure that credit union facilities remain open to residents and that those with accounts with NewCred are protected in the event that it ceases trading. The Council was approached by LCCU who had been in turn approached by the Association of British Credit Unions Limited (ABCUL). ABCUL identified LCCU as the most credible option to rescue NewCred. LCCU propose a Transfer of Engagements from NewCred, in effect a takeover, of the organisation. To do so LCCU sought capital investment in the form of a 10 year loan of £600,000. This loan is larger than the amount sought by NewCred for two reasons. Firstly LCCU believe NewCred may have underestimated the capitalisation required. Secondly LCCU is a larger credit union. Taking on NewCred would push it past the threshold of 10,000 members and this require it to hold a capital/assets ratio of 8% rather than the 5% that applied to NewCred as a stand alone organisation. Full Council agreed the budget provision of a £600,000 loan, as required by the Councils constitution subject to agreement of the terms of the loan which were delegated to Cabinet. Cabinet agreed the proposed heads of terms and delegated final decision making ... view the full minutes text for item 1.