Decision The Deputy Mayor agreed to extend the current stores management contract with Travis Perkins together with the lease (in line with the contract) for the further 3 years as set out in the original tender of 2011 and contract. Reasons for Recommendation RMS considers the cost of the first option is prohibitive. The cost of re-employing the TUPE staff will be more than the original £280,000 savings. There would be an initial negative upfront cash flow requirement for the purchase of the stock in excess of £500,000 and a loss of rental income of £75,000 per annum. Further immeasurable costs will accrue from the requirement of purchasing new stores IT system and the effect of the change and transitional change period on operating practices and performance. The option to re-tender has to look at how the current contract has performed and weigh up the likely benefits of a change in supplier. The result of the original tender clearly favoured Travis Perkins in price and experience against two of the other major national providers. Since then Travis Perkins have won 7 out of 10 of this type of tender nationally at comparable or even higher prices than charged at LBN. The nearest comparator’s rates being 5.5% higher than RMS in a recent benchmarking exercise. A further benchmarking exercise against other national suppliers demonstrated Travis Perkins were in excess of ... view the full minutes text for item 4.
Word for word from the decision Newham published for this meeting.Source: mgov.newham.gov.uk
Is it in the Forward Plan? Yes Date report published 25th March 2015
Date of Decision 2nd April 2015
Subject: Extension to existing Supply of Building Material and Stores Management Contract.
Source: Community and Environment
Wards affected: All
Outline of Proposed Procurement and Executive Summary of Outcomes
The current contract was let on an initial 5 years with an option to extend by a further 3 years. We are currently coming up to the end of the 4th year and this report seeks permission to take up this 3 year extension.
There are 3 possible options available:-
1. To take the service back in-house. To re-employ the staff TUPE’d to Travis Perkins back. To purchase the stock and the necessary IT systems and provide the same or better service. 2. Re-tender the outsourced management and provision of the stores. This would mean a full OJEU tender and the TUPE transfer of Travis Perkins staff to any new supplier. 3. To extend the contract with Travis Perkins for a further 3 year period.
Executive Summary of Outcomes. By choosing to extend the current contract by a further 3 years would give the following benefits:-
• A continuation of the financial benefits, in line with the current £2.0 million, over the extension period. • A continuation of current RMS service performance on completing jobs on time, doing the jobs in the least number of visits and the consequent high customer satisfaction levels. • A realistic timescale to procure a new supply and management contract while maintaining service provision and IT system integrity throughout the process. • The option of a 1% ‘community pot’ available for use for any local community initiative/ apprenticeship/ training scheme.
1 Recommendation The mayor is asked to extend the current stores management contract with Travis Perkins together with the lease (in line with the contract) for the further 3 years as set out in the original tender of 2011 and contract.
Reasons for Recommendation RMS considers the cost of the first option is prohibitive. The cost of re-employing the TUPE staff will be more than the original £280,000 savings. There would be an initial negative upfront cash flow requirement for the purchase of the stock in excess of £500,000 and a loss of rental income of £75,000 per annum. Further immeasurable costs will accrue from the requirement of purchasing new stores IT system and the effect of the change and transitional change period on operating practices and performance.
The option to re-tender has to look at how the current contract has performed and weigh up the likely benefits of a change in supplier. The result of the original tender clearly favoured Travis Perkins in price and experience against two of the other major national providers. Since then Travis Perkins have won 7 out of 10 of this type of tender nationally at comparable or even higher prices than charged at LBN. The nearest comparator’s rates being 5.5% higher than RMS in a recent benchmarking exercise. A further benchmarking exercise against other national suppliers demonstrated Travis Perkins were in excess of 13% cheaper at this time.
The current tender is open-book and other material suppliers will be using a similar range of manufacturers with similar costs to all suppliers. Travis Perkins have already depreciated their initial capital costs over the initial 5 year contract but these costs would have to be reflected by other bidders, making them less competitive. The gamble of an immediate re-tender is that of a possible minor material and profit reduction against the unknown risk of disruption and the quality of management.
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.