Resolved
It was agreed to consider the report in public on the following grounds: a) There is a clear public interest in matters of member conduct being considered in public; b) In this case, whilst personal data was disclosed, the facts did not justify the matter being considered in private or the report being withheld as exempt information. The events all took place in a public meeting and the comments were made to the meeting as a whole. All of the complainants attended the meeting as speakers or objectors and no personal information about them was disclosed beyond their names. Councillor Corbett is a public figure; the comments which are subject of the complaint are in the public domain. The Monitoring Officer informed the Committee that Ch&I Associates were appointed to investigate the complaint. The investigation was undertaken by Alex Oram and the findings were attached as an appendix to the report. [name removed] was critical of Councillor Ian Corbett but found that there was insufficient evidence to disclose a breach of the Code of Conduct. The Monitoring Officer stated that he was mindful to accept the findings and his provisional view was to dismiss the complaint and write to Councillor Ian Corbett to remind him of his behaviour. In reaching this view the Monitoring officer said that he had taken into account: 1) The Report’s findings and criticisms of Councillor Ian Corbett; 2) Councillor Corbett (since the complaint was made) has decided not to seek re-election; 3) Councillor Corbett has elected not to participate in Licensing Sub-Committee hearings; and 4) A new Licensing Committee will be appointed in May after the local elections and will be fully trained. The Council can ensure that equality issues are addressed as part of its training. Members asked whether the deciding factor to accept the findings was because Councillor Corbett would not be seeking re-election. The Monitoring Officer stated that it was only part of the reason; Councillor Corbett had advised the investigator that objections could only be raised on the grounds of the licensing objections. The point he had been trying to make when making his comments were that the petition presented had been signed with addresses from places as far away as Kuwait and the USA and were not local to the application. The Chair commented that there was no evidence to suggest that everyone that had signed the petition presented to the Licensing Sub-Committee were Muslims, as Councillor Corbett was alleged to have said. The Chair said that whilst she understood that any objections to an application should come from ... view the full minutes text for item 7.