For the reasons set out in the report and in line with the Corporate Debt Policy , Cabinet RESOLVED to AGREE: To approve the write-off of all unrecoverable debt arising from Penalty Charge Notice activity, totalling £32,423,496, from the Council ’ s accounts. Alternatives Considered £9.14 million worth of the debt had been returned by bailiffs as unrecoverable, for a variety of reasons, which included warrants expiring and vulnerable debtors being unable to pay. As per the CPR rules Part 83.3 paragraph 3 - a warrant of execution was only valid for a period of 12 months from the date it was issued. The alternatives considered to further pursue recovery of aged debt were: Re-registering the warrants with the court after the expiry date as per CPR Rules Part 83.3. Paragraph 4. However there would be further associated costs - £8 to reregister each warrant. This was not considered a viable option as there was a low probability of being able to recover the outstanding debt through further action as the warrants had already been with the debt collectors previously for a period of 12 months and not recovered. To refer the cases to debt collectors to enforce as a debt or take legal action through a County Court Judgement. In the current economic climate this was not considered a viable option, as there was little prospect of recovering the debt owed.
Word for word from the decision Newham published for this meeting.Source: mgov.newham.gov.uk
Report title Parking Debt Write-Off Date of Meeting 9th March 2021 Lead Officer and Jon Shaw contact details Interim Head of Parking Corporate Jamie Blake, Corporate Director - Environment & Director, Job title Sustainable Transport Lead Member Cllr James Asser, Cabinet Member - Environment, Highways and Sustainable Transport Key Decision? Yes Reasons: Over £500k, Exempt N/A information & Grounds Wards Affected None Appendices None (if any)
1 Executive Summary 1.1 This report seeks approval to write-off unrecoverable parking debt relating to Penalty Charge Notice (PCN) activity between 2014/15 and 2019/20. The total sum being requested for write-off is £32.42m. 1.2 Debt write-offs are an integral part of sound financial management and will also enable the council’s accounts to be finalised without qualification. The debt amount recommended for write-off was fully recognised within the bad debt provision during the 2019/20 closure of accounts process and was subsequently part of the 2019/20 audit which has been completed. As all of these debts have been fully provided for, the recommendation in this report has no impact on the council’s overall financial position.
2 Recommendations 2.1 For the reasons set out in the report and in line with the Corporate Debt Policy, Cabinet is recommended to: Approve the write-off of all unrecoverable debt arising from Penalty Charge Notice (PCN) activity, totalling £32,423,496, from the council’s accounts.
1 3 Background 3.1 Parking enforcement and management is an essential and important activity to help the Council deliver its traffic management duties, improve road safety, reduce congestion and by doing do, improve air quality and the quality of life of our residents. Better traffic flow and improving conditions for more walking and cycling is also an important objective of enforcing contraventions. Contraventions are enforced through the issuance of Penalty Change Notices (PCN).
3.2The enforcement of parking is a heavily regulated function and as such there are a variety of reasons why enforcement bodies like the council may not be able to recover all Penalty Charge Notices (PCN) issued. These can include system and process issues, the inability to locate the owners of offending vehicles, and the vehicle owner having no means to pay.
3.3Where the council has been unable to recover income relating to a PCN, the amount owed becomes a debt, and these debts will not always be recovered. As with all other enforcement authorities, the council is required to ensure it makes appropriate arrangements to manage these debts, including writing-off ‘bad’ debt that it deems unrecoverable. 3.4 In deciding whether to write-off debts it is necessary to have regard to the fiduciary duty owed and to act reasonably, justly and proportionately. As there is no prospect of the debt being repaid, the council cannot hold this debt on its balance sheet as a debtor and it needs to be written off.
3.5Ordinarily, the council would manage debt that it deems to be unrecoverable on a regular basis, for example, annually in-line with the closing of the council’s accounts. However, debt relating to PCN activity has not been written-off since 2014/15, primarily due to on-going attempts to maximise the amount of debt recovered.
3.6A detailed review of all outstanding parking debt was undertaken during the 2019/20 closure of accounts process. Following this review is has been established that a significant number of these debts are no longer collectable and need to be considered for write-off, with the council having exhausted all routes to recovering the amounts owed.
3.7The reasons for the accumulation of this unrecoverable debt can be broken down into four main categories.
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.