Resolved
For the reasons set out in the report, Cabinet RESOLVED to AGREE : That Liberty Charge Ltd, be appointed as our preferred Charge Point Operator for this procurement, to deliver, operate and maintain 400 electric vehicle chargers for the agreed concession period. Alternatives Considered 1. The alternative to engaging with potential partners over reduced cost options for charge point delivery would be to continue to rely on increasingly uncertain central government funding initiatives to fund a conventional procurement exercise. 2. This would require a 25% match fund from Council funds, although it is acknowledged that the market is increasingly offering to cover this match funding contribution. 3. Therefore, if we are to continue our electric vehicle rollout without utilising scarce Council capital, we must continue to explore potential market partnerships to assist with our EVCP delivery, while being mindful of securing the best option for the Council from any agreements with those potential partners. 4. Officers have also been mindful not to entertain any exclusivity agreements with either UBER or the successful bidder, so as not to constrain any further market discussions in the future, and Newham remains very much ‘open for business’ for any charge point operators who wish to present us with their propositions. 5. In addition, there was also an option to not deliver any new electric charging points at all and to refuse the UBER funding, but this would not meet with our corporate aims on air quality or public health. Therefore, this option was quickly disregarded 6. There were also a number of alternatives options regarding the route to market, in particular the TTPL and ESPO purchasing frameworks. TTPL Frameworks had a Limited pool of suppliers - following an initial assessment only 4 suppliers had the resource and existing infrastructure to respond to an RFP. ESPO was not considered suitable due to the expiry date, and it will not be feasible to fully coordinate with the other Local Authorities and run/assess an RFP within the timelines. 7. Finally, following the limited response to the tendering exercise, it could have been possible to not appoint and re-tender. However, the supplier chosen was fully compliant in their responses to the ITT, and any delay would have both risked the UBER funding deal and delayed any significant improvement in our air quality. Neither of these would have been an acceptable outcome. For the reasons set out in the report, Cabinet RESOLVED to AGREE : That Liberty Charge Ltd, be appointed as our preferred Charge Point Operator for this procurement, to deliver, operate and maintain 400 electric vehicle chargers for the agreed concession period. Alternatives Considered 1. The alternative to engaging with potential partners over reduced cost options for charge point delivery would be to continue to rely on increasingly uncertain central government funding initiatives to fund a conventional procurement exercise. 2. This would require a 25% match fund from Council funds, although it is acknowledged that the market is increasingly offering to cover this match funding contribution. 3. Therefore, if we are to continue our electric vehicle rollout without utilising scarce Council capital, we must continue to explore potential market partnerships to assist with our EVCP delivery, while being mindful of securing the best option for the Council from any agreements with those potential partners. 4. Officers have also been mindful not to entertain any exclusivity agreements with either UBER or the successful bidder, so as not to constrain any further market discussions in the future, and Newham remains very much ‘open for business’ for any charge point operators who wish to present us with their propositions. 5. In addition, there was also an option to not deliver any new electric charging points at all and to refuse the UBER funding, but this would not meet with our corporate aims on air quality or public health. Therefore, this option was quickly disregarded 6. There were also a number of alternatives options regarding the route to market, in particular the TTPL and ESPO purchasing frameworks. TTPL Frameworks had a Limited pool of suppliers - following an initial assessment only 4 suppliers had the resource and existing infrastructure to respond to an RFP. ... view the full minutes text for item 8.