Resolved
For the reasons set out in the report and its appendices Cabinet RESOLVED to AGREE: i) That where appropriate and depending on the development, to adjust the freehold ground rent it charges developers to ensure they are set at a level that enables the developer to reduce leaseholder ground rents; ii) That the target for agreements with developers should be a maximum of £250 pa for a 1 bed property, £350 pa for a 2 bed and £450 for 3 beds or larger; iii) Any adjustment by the Council to the freehold ground rent would be subject to the developer agreeing at the same time to reduce the ground rents it charges residents to an acceptable level and consistent with (i) and (ii) above; and iv) The adjustment to the freehold ground rent in (i) should be to a level that is no more than the total of the ground rents the developer receives after reducing the amount of ground rent it charges to residents. Alternatives considered Do Nothing The Council has the option to rely on the enforcement actions by the CMA where any ground rents charged by developers are not in line. However, to do nothing will possibly hinder existing leaseholders from re-mortgaging or selling their properties and it is therefore considered unreasonable for the Council to not step in and attempt to influence the position. Removal of ground rent in its entirety The Council could elect to remove ground rents altogether from its head leases in return for developers doing the same for residents. This would bring existing developments into line with new developments following the 2022 legislation. However, officers consider (i) this goes further than is necessary to remedy the problems of selling or obtaining a mortgage and (ii) the ground rents received by the Council provide important income for the delivery of its services and so it would be detrimental to reduce by more than is necessary to address the underlying problem and may breach the Council’s wider fiduciary duty. It is also likely to more difficult to get agreement from developers for such an extreme response to the current challenges.