To adopt the recommended Improvements within the report, draft consultation and engagement plan and leaflet and ask that they be incorporated into the overall consultation and engagement plan To ask that Scrutiny works with the Partnership and Policy Team to further refine the programme of activity and processes To adopt the recommended Improvements within the report, draft consultation and engagement plan and leaflet and ask that they be incorporated into the overall consultation and engagement plan To ask that Scrutiny works with the Partnership and Policy Team ... view the full minutes text for item 7.
Word for word from the decision Newport published for this meeting.Source: democracy.newport.gov.uk
Subject Consultation and Engagement Purpose To report to Cabinet on the process for 2014/15, lessons learnt and seek approval for the programme of activity for 2015/16 process
Author Rhys Cornwall, Partnership and Policy Manager
Ward City wide
Summary During 2014/15 Newport City Council undertook a significant consultation and engagement process that supported key budget decisions. This report outlines some lessons learned from last year and recommends improvements to the process for this year. It also provides a draft consultation and engagement plan and suggested (draft) budget leaflet.
Proposal For Cabinet to consider the recommended improvements, consultation and engagement plan and budget leaflet and to agree the direction for this work to support the 2016/17 budget setting process
Action by Head of People and Business Change
Timetable Immediate This report was prepared after consultation with:
Business Improvement Manager PR and Communications Manager Head of People and Business Change Head of Finance Head of Law and Standards Background Ahead of the 2015/16 Budget setting process, the need for a wider reaching and more participatory programme of consultation and engagement was recognised. The Partnership and Policy Team were given responsibility for organising and leading on the engagement programme alongside colleagues from Finance, Business Improvement and Communications. A two phased programme of engagement was undertaken. A review of the methods used and the lessons learned is given below to inform the programme for the 2016/17 budget.
Review of engagement activities undertaken for the 2015/16 Budget
Phase 1 - Pre-proposals stage branded as the ‘budget conversation’.
We received over 1,000 responses to the ‘Budget Conversation’. We employed a variety of mechanisms to achieve this:
Ward meetings – Heads of Services gave an agreed ‘budget challenge’ presentation which outlined the scale of savings required and encouraged members of the public to give their suggestions and respond to the consultation exercise. Face to face interviews using a template survey were held in public venues and locations across Newport. They were resource intensive but created a public presence for the ‘budget conversation’ and generated a significant number of responses. These were also circulated during NCC events e.g. Next Steps Event for young people. Online questionnaires – asked the same questions as face to face interviews. Generated a significant proportion of Phase 1 responses and required much less employee time. They were easily circulated to partner organisations and interest groups e.g. business contacts. Printed Questionnaires - mainly circulated through Newport Matters in November but also available at NCC public buildings. Also generated a significant proportion of responses. Online Budget Simulator – intended to demonstrate to the public the complexity and constraints of setting a balanced budget. In practice this was difficult to set up realistically and wasn’t used as much as was hoped. The main issue was the level of detail required to show how reductions in budgets would result in impacts on service which meant that the simulation was limited. However there was no cost involved and this was one part of a wider programme. East / West Engagement Events – these events led by Cabinet and SLT were poorly attended, despite being well publicised and being held in accessible venues in the evening. Possible reasons for the poor attendance could be a general disinterest or apathy with the process or a higher degree of confidence in the Local Authority’s ability to manage finances. However, the poor weather at the time, timing before formal proposals were released or the other opportunities for engagement that were offered could have also had an impact.
Phase 2 – Formal consultation once proposals were made public
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
Revenue Budget Outturn - 2025/26Cabinet - 1. Noted the outturn position, which was subject to audit; and the major variances for the year (Sections 1...
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.