CouncilMonitor
194 principal councils 228,996 meetings since 2000 2.8 million official papers archived Straight from each council's own publication system
Newport City Council
Cabinet, Monday 20 March 2017 at 11.00am

Response to White Paper

Agreed Executive 1 paper

Cabinet agreed this item on Monday 20 March 2017. Below is the council's own wording, with the papers it was decided on.

Item3

Resolved

The Leader of the Council introduced a report which presented a series of proposed responses to the questions posed in the White Paper. The Leader considered that the White Paper was an opportunity to suggest ground-breaking ways of providing public services and was somewhat disappointed that this was a missed opportunity. The Chief Executive explained that the key themes covered in the document were: Regional Working; Voluntary Mergers; Local Leadership; Community Councils and Elections & Voting The report presented to Cabinet expressed the view that the white paper presented a traditional approach to reform as it focuses on structures with little attention to the needs of the communities local government serves. It makes the assumption that the way to tackle future challenges lies in greater levels of collaboration between local authorities and across the public sector. However, collaboration between authorities is already extensive and significant savings have already been achieved. The report informed Cabinet that whilst the creation of larger authorities now seems off the agenda, the thinking behind the white paper seems stuck in the thinking of structures. Local Government is now being urged and instructed to create regional, sub-regional and local structures with little thought given to how we can create local systems serving local communities using the social capital within places. Savings can be achieved through the sharing of senior staff but in overall terms, these will be marginal and reduce the capacity and capability to deal with possibly the most challenging environment local government has ever faced. Creating new structures also takes times and in some cases will be dependent upon the introduction of legislation. The danger is that time and energy appears to be focused in the wrong place and ultimately new structures are just new ways of doing things in the same way. What is needed is a fundamentally different approach to engaging with communities and a new approach to service design. The report pointed out that more innovative models are now being created which focus much more on developing local systems using the collective capacity within a place to help meet the challenge of creating sustainable service delivery to help people live well. The report considered that the White Paper was an opportunity for Wales to set itself apart as a country determined to create a new model for the delivery of public services. Unfortunately it was considered that the white paper will not achieve this. The Chief Executive welcomed the shift by the new Cabinet Secretary from reorganisation proposals to a focus on putting in place collaborative arrangements to ensure councils work more effectively together. The white paper describes further work towards regional working, collaboration and shared services. The proposed response suggests the need for local negotiation informed for service delivery. The principle of local government is the need to make decisions locally. Local Authorities need to have the flexibility to decide locally how they consider services may best be provided Cabinet Members agreed the proposed report set out in the report and ...
Word for word from the decision Newport published for this meeting. Source: democracy.newport.gov.uk

Follow this further

Built from Newport's papers

What the report saysPro

Report to Cabinet

Report Cabinet Part 1

Date: 20 March 2017

Item No: please see above

Subject Consultation Response to Welsh Government white paper on Local Government – “Reforming Local Government: Resilient and Renewed” Purpose To agree the response prepared by the Chief Executive to the white paper on local government.

Author Will Godfrey, Chief Executive

Ward All

Summary Welsh Government published its white paper on reforming local government on 31st January, 2017. This is the latest in a series of plans from Welsh Government outlining proposals for the future of local government.

Consultation responses are required by 11th April 2017 which is of course within the purdah period for the local government elections. The white paper is a lengthy document which raises a number of key issues which require careful consideration. This meeting is therefore the first opportunity for a report to be presented for discussion. As there are a number of issues which may be politically contentious it would be inappropriate to discuss and submit a response within the purdah period. Therefore some questions have been left unanswered in the proposed response.

Proposal To agree the response to the Welsh Government white paper on reform of local government.

Action by Chief Executive

Timetable Immediate This report was prepared after consultation with:

 Chief Executive  Strategic Directors (People and Place)  Heads of Service Background Structure of White Paper

The key themes covered in the document are as follows:

 Regional Working  Voluntary Mergers  Local Leadership  Community Councils  Elections & Voting

The consultation poses 33 questions for consideration. Attached at appendix 1 to this report are the suggested responses to the questions.

In many ways the white paper is a disappointingly traditional approach to reform. It focuses on structures with very little attention to the needs of the communities local government serves. It makes the assumption that the way to tackle future challenges lies in greater levels of collaboration between local authorities and across the public sector. Collaboration between authorities is already extensive and significant savings have already been achieved.

Whilst the creation of larger authorities now seems off the agenda, the thinking behind the white paper seems stuck in the thinking of structures. Local Government is now being urged and instructed to create regional, sub-regional and local structures with no thought given to how we can create local systems serving local communities using the social capital within places. Savings can be achieved through the sharing of senior staff but in overall terms, these will be marginal and reduce the capacity and capability to deal with possibly the most challenging environment local government has ever faced. Creating new structures also takes times and in some cases will be dependent upon the introduction of legislation. The danger is that time and energy is focused in the wrong place and ultimately new structures are just new ways of doing things the same way. What is needed is a fundamentally different approach to engaging with communities and a new approach to service design.

So this really is an opportunity missed. More innovative models are now being created which focus much more on developing local systems using the collective capacity within a place to help meet the challenge of creating sustainable service delivery to help people live well. This white paper was an opportunity for Wales to set itself apart as a country determined to create a new model for the delivery of public services. Unfortunately the white paper will not achieve this.

Nevertheless it is now appropriate to focus on the issues raised in the document and the proposed responses to the questions.

Set out below is more information about the key issues:

Regional Working

Read every report as text, not just the decision

Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.

Papers for this item

Kept in our archive, download once signed in
PDF
Response to White PaperReport 278 KB DownloadRead as text

At this meeting

Whole meeting

Who was there

9 of 9 attended
DW
Councillor Debbie WilcoxChair, present
PC
Councillor Paul CockeramCommittee Member, present
GG
Councillor Gail GilesCommittee Member, present
DH
Councillor Debbie HarveyCommittee Member, present
RJ
Councillor Roger JeavonsCommittee Member, present
RP
Councillor Robert PooleCommittee Member, present
JR
Councillor John RichardsCommittee Member, present
RT
Councillor Ray TrumanCommittee Member, present
MW
Councillor Mark WhitcuttCommittee Member, present

On this subject at Newport

Search all
  1. Response to White PaperThis decision
  2. Draft Response to Welsh Government Transport White Paper ConsultationAgreed

More from Newport Cabinet

All decisions
MeetingDecisionOutcome
8 Jul 2026 Annual Welsh Language Monitoring Report 2025-26Cabinet approved and recommended the monitoring report to Full Council. Approved Open
8 Jul 2026 Safer Newport Community Safety Partnership Annual Report 2025-26Cabinet approved the Safer Newport Community Safety Partnership Annual Report 2025-2026 for publication in line with ... Approved Open
8 Jul 2026 Newport Library Strategy 2026-29Cabinet adopted the and proceeded to publication. Approved Open
8 Jul 2026 Work ProgrammeCabinet agreed the . The Leader gave the following announcement in relation to a package of targeted one-off investme... Agreed Open
17 Jun 2026 Revenue Budget Outturn - 2025/26Cabinet - 1. Noted the outturn position, which was subject to audit; and the major variances for the year (Sections 1... Noted Open

We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies