Endorsed the following recommendations presented by the Local Environment Overview & Scrutiny Panel: That, the current structural arrangements for the planning committee be continued; That, the Council continues to provide and further encourage member training on planning issues to ensure a comprehensive understanding of planning policy and material considerations; That, Group Leaders play a more active role in organising substitutions for planning committee meetings on a meeting-by-meeting basis and for those members who regularly do not attend meetings. Members should also be more proactive in notifying their Group Leaders of their intended absence by 12noon the previous day to a planning committee meeting. This is to be reinforced during Member training. Note: A later start time of future Planning meetings may need to be considered by the incoming administration.
Word for word from the decision North Kesteven published for this meeting.Source: democracy.n-kesteven.gov.uk
Local Environment Overview and Scrutiny Panel Task and Finish Group
Lead member: Councillor Michael Rook
Members: Councillor John C Clarke Councillor Brian Drain Councillor Ron Oxby Councillor Stuart Tweedale FOREWORD
Councillor Michael Rook Lead Member
Councillor Councillor Councillor Councillor John Clarke Brian Drain Ron Oxby Stuart Tweedale
In April 2006 the Council agreed to replace the two North and South planning committees, with one committee that delegated to two sub-committees, upon a recommendation from the Executive Board. It was agreed by the Board to review this decision after one year of operation.
This Task and Finish Group was therefore established by the Local Environment Overview and Scrutiny Panel on 22nd November 2006 to undertake its own review of the impact of the Council’s decision and report its findings and recommendations before the Council’s year end in May 2007 but for the incoming Executive Board to consider. We were asked to scrutinise the impact of these changes on the role and responsibilities on elected members, applicants, agents, the public, and those officers involved in the administration of development control matters in the planning department.
We have consulted with all members, planning officers, legal and member services officers, parish councils, agents, developers and other local authorities, and undertook various aspects of desktop research to provide us with a broader range of evidence as possible on which to base our conclusions and recommendations. We found that the current system was working to a high standard and have therefore recommended that this continue with a few minor amendments.
1 Our report has been published using a new style and format on a trial basis, as part of ongoing developments of the overview and scrutiny function.
The Task and Finish group wish to thank all those who participated, and especially to Rebecca Chadwick and Helen Bayne for their splendid professional support in directing, advising and researching our findings.
This report has been considered and endorsed by the Local Environment Overview and Scrutiny Panel, who made one minor alteration by including reference to member training within the third of our recommendations.
Cllr Michael Rook – Lead Member for the Planning Committee Structure Task & Finish Group.
2 EVIDENCE
• Analysis of a canvass of a selection of 21 other district and borough councils (including the “Daventry Group”), Lincolnshire Councils, and other rural Councils. (Appendix 1)
• Round table interview with Planning Officers (Appendix 2)
• Analysis of questionnaire to all Members (Appendix 3)
• Interview responses from the Head of Legal and Member Services and the Member Services Manager (Appendix 4)
• Analysis of a questionnaire of agents and applicants (Appendix 5)
• Customer survey (Appendix 6)
• Statutory performance results (Appendix 7)
• Assessment of planning applications considered by the Committee: 2005/06 and 2006/07 (Appendix 8)
• Telephone survey of Parish Councils (Appendix 9)
3 FINDINGS 1. Benchmarking (Appendix 1)
1.1As a foundation for the evidence gathered by the Task & Finish Group (TFG), a benchmarking exercise was undertaken to identify planning committee arrangements at other authorities. Lincolnshire authorities, the Daventry Group and rural East Midlands authorities were studied.
1.2The comparative spreadsheet showing other Councils’ Planning Development processes is attached at Appendix 1 and shows that, if there was one sure thing, it was “that there was no one-size-fits-all solution” at work in the country as a whole.
1.3Of the 22 Councils contacted (including NK itself), NKDC was the only one that had 100% of its Elected Members involved in planning committee work.
1.4One Council, (Lincoln City) however, decided its own major applications in full Council using all Members, but had one dedicated planning committee for normal applications with no substitutes.
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.