Approved the implementation of Levels 1 and 2 of the Garden Support Scheme with immediate effect through the continued use of Hill Holt Wood; Approved the implementation of Level 3 of the Garden Support Scheme, on a six-month trial basis, for customers currently not receiving the existing grass cutting service; Agreed that Contract Procedures to seek tenders for the Level 3 element of the Scheme be waived and that a Legal Agreement be created with Hill Holt Wood.
Word for word from the decision North Kesteven published for this meeting.Source: democracy.n-kesteven.gov.uk
To seek approval to submit an item to the next Executive Board on a review of the existing garden support scheme.
Summary
In August 2008, the Garden Maintenance Service was introduced in partnership with Hill Holt Wood. The service provides for a one-off garden clearance for those gardens where tenants have struggled to keep on top of regular maintenance. The service is earmarked for those tenants who are regarded as vulnerable. The Authority made a contribution of £25,000 for the service and after the first year a value for money review was undertaken which was referred to the Environment and Communities Overview and Scrutiny Panel. This report is attached at Appendix 1.
Key findings from the review were:
87 gardens were referred in to the scheme in the first year operation with 82 suitable for works to be carried out. This makes the unit cost for gardens improved £316* There was a seasonal bias on the demand for the service, the most requests for assistance being made from June to December. Overall satisfaction of tenants receiving the service was high at 90.5%. 42.9% of respondents said they needed further help with their gardens.
(*However this does not acknowledge that some gardens required extreme amounts of clearance work taking in excess of one weeks working time for the Hill Holt Wood team)
Options for the improvement of this service were discussed with the Overview and Scrutiny Panel and these options were:
Negotiate an improved contract with Hill Holt Wood. Provide the service in-house for an equivalent cost. Proceed through a tender exercise to appoint a private contractor.
The Overview and Scrutiny Panel considered information regarding the costs of the Council employing a gardener directly and also a quotation had been obtained from the private sector to carry out garden maintenance. On balance, it was felt that the private sector would not provide a flexible and cost effective service in the future. It was also felt that it would not be appropriate at this stage for the Council to employ additional staff to undertake this work and as such, the Overview and Scrutiny Panel requested that the Council negotiate an improved contract with Hill Holt Wood.
Negotiations have commenced with the following principles in mind:
Improving the value for money of the service currently provided. Offering more regular garden maintenance taking into account feedback from the questionnaire exercise. The Hill Holt Wood have an opportunity to use funding provided by the future jobs fund for new labour into the development of this service.
At the same time, Officers have been giving some thought of the existing grass cutting service provided to tenants through the Council’s grounds maintenance contract. Currently, for a fortnightly cut tenants are charged 0.62p per week providing an income of approximately £6,000. However, the cost to the Housing Revenue account of this service is £36,000, meaning that those tenants taking up the service are subsidised by over £30,000.
No information is being collected on the satisfaction levels with the service although anecdotally, tenants have complained about the quality and frequency of these cuts.
Officers have taken both reviews to the Housing Quality Practice Group and discussed the possible way forward in terms of developing a more comprehensive garden support service. The details of this are attached in Appendix 2 and break the service down across three levels:
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.