That charges for garden waste be increased for 2016/17 as follows: Annual charge for collection of first garden waste bin £30 Annual charge for collection of each additional garden waste bin (up to 4 total) £12 Provision of first brown wheeled bin £12 Provision of each additional brown wheeled bin £30 That charges be reviewed annually.
Word for word from the decision North Kesteven published for this meeting.Source: democracy.n-kesteven.gov.uk
Report of the Environment Overview and Scrutiny Panel Task and Finish Group – Green Waste Service.
The scope: “Establish the cost and viability of the garden waste collection service and, if suitable, derive any recommendations.”
To undertake a review of the NKDC green waste service with particular focus on the cost of the service and charges made to subscribers. The Task and Finish Group is concerned that if the charge made to Council Tax payers subscribing to the green waste service does not cover the cost of the service, then all those not using and benefitting from the service, are effectively subsidising it.
Overview
It should be noted that the NKDC green waste service is only responsible for the collection of green waste and the delivery of that waste to a Lincolnshire County Council waste site. The confidentiality surrounding the LCC waste disposal service meant that the T&F Group was unable to follow the green waste service beyond the point of delivery and is unable to comment on the viability and value of the LCC waste disposal service.
Firstly it has to be stressed that the NKDC green waste service is valued by subscribers. The service has approximately 31,000 subscribers (out of a total of 49,233 households in NKDC) and currently enjoys a steady increase in subscriber numbers of around 1000 per annum.
The T&F Group found a well-managed service that is flexible, well resourced, and efficient. Following the 2014 route review the service is running at optimum efficiency with collection split over 4 lorries providing a flexible service that responds well to seasonal demands.
The T&F Group wishes to commend Nina Camm, Environment Manager, for the day to day management of the service and Mark Taylor, Head of Environment and Public Protection, for the financial management of the service.
Methodology
The T&F Group composed five questions designed to ascertain the financial status of the service; the viability of the service; any hidden costs within the service; the impact of the Central Lincolnshire Local Plan on the service; and the relevance of the £25 charge.
Appendix 1, details the answers provided by Mark Taylor, Head of Environment and Public Protection, to the initial questions raised by the Group at the meeting of the Task & Finish Group on the 8th September 2015.
1. Does the garden waste service pay for itself currently? If not, what is the level of subsidy per Council Tax payer not taking part in the scheme? Current projections for 2015/16 are for there to be a shortfall of income to expenditure of £213,000. However savings made within the service along with a more realistic reallocation of the costs within the various waste streams the shortfall in income was revised to £152,200. Whilst the service is well managed the income generated from the current subscription charge of £25 does not cover the costs of the service. Therefore the service is effectively being subsidised through the Council Tax by all householders (not just those not taking part in the scheme.) The level of subsidy per household, based on current household numbers of 49,233 is £3.10. It was noted that this meant service users were effectively paying £28.10 for their brown bin and non-service users were paying £3.10 to subsidise the service.
2. Price increase: It was confirmed that in order to achieve full cost recovery and remove the burden of subsidy from non subscribers, the price for the green waste service needs to be increased. The difficulty is in quantifying the price point at which subscribers would leave the service leading to reduced income and a loss in efficiency. There is also another interesting consideration that increased take-up could lead to increased costs and reduced efficiency through the requirement to allocate additional resources to the service.
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.