CouncilMonitor
194 principal councils 228,996 meetings since 2000 2.8 million official papers archived Straight from each council's own publication system
North Kesteven District Council
Executive Board, Tuesday 5 February 2019 at 1.00pm

Task and Finish Group report: Planning Gain for Health Provision

Approved Executive 1 paper

Executive Board approved this item on Tuesday 5 February 2019. Below is the council's own wording, with the papers it was decided on.

Item116

Resolved

That a workshop including management and operational staff from the CCGs and the Council plus elected member representatives and NHS representation be arranged as an initial step to more fully scope opportunities and outcomes and prioritise the range of opportunities. 2. That a required outcome of the workshop exercise should be a regular (e.g. quarterly) meeting between the Council, the CCGs and including NHS England representation. This should include operational staff such as planners, but also senior management from both sides. The objective would initially focus on progress in developing better joint working but would include operational overview and a sharing of strategic level issues. 3. That the Council undertakes a piece of work to study the opportunities, constraints, costs and benefits of direct involvement in healthcare infrastructure provision such as health centres. 1. That a workshop including management and operational staff from the CCGs and the Council plus elected member representatives and NHS representation be arranged as an initial step to more fully scope opportunities and outcomes and prioritise the range of opportunities. 2. That a required outcome of the workshop exercise should be a regular (e.g. quarterly) meeting between the Council, the CCGs and including NHS England representation. This should include operational staff such as planners, but also senior management from both sides. The objective would initially focus on progress in developing better joint working but would include operational overview and a sharing of strategic level issues. 3. That the Council undertakes a piece of work to study the opportunities, constraints, costs and benefits of direct involvement in healthcare infrastructure provision such as health centres. Reasons for decision: · The Planning Gain for Health Provision Task and Finish Group (TFG) was set up in 2018 under the Environment Overview and Scrutiny Panel of North Kesteven District Council. · The Group had considered evidence from a range of witnesses including North Kesteven management and officers and representatives from the health service. In addition, North Kesteven officers undertook extensive analytical work to provide valuable written evidence. · The Central Lincolnshire Local Plan adopted in 2017 provides for significant growth in North Kesteven in the period to 2036. The Plan makes detailed provision to ensure that infrastructure provision keeps pace with new housing and economic development, and contained a number of policies which specifically allow and encourage developer contributions (often known as ‘planning gain’) toward health provision. · Concern had been expressed among elected Members that these policies may not be working sufficiently well. In particular Members were concerned at the number of cases heard by the planning committee where no contribution was sought or a consultation response of ‘no comment’ was received from the health service. Members were also concerned at reports that due to resource limitations the NHS was routinely failing to seek contributions from entire categories of smaller qualifying developments. · The TFG concluded that there was little evidence of large-scale opportunities of planning gain having been missed in the past and that monitoring and management of contributions was very well handled. However there was room for improvement in increasing uptake from routine applications, though the financial returns were likely to be relatively modest. · The TFG also concluded that the system around planning gain for healthcare was a complex one facing challenges from growth, demographic change and the rapidly evolving pattern of delivery of healthcare and wellbeing services. Looking to the future the TFG found that the operation of the system could be significantly improved. It was essential to ensure maximum healthcare provision from all possible development to satisfy the needs of existing as well as future residents. · Crucial to any improvement, would be closer working between the Council and Clinical Commissioning Groups (CCGs). The TFG found that management and officers on both sides were keen to work together, but that both sides needed to ... view the full minutes text for item 116.
Word for word from the decision North Kesteven published for this meeting. Source: democracy.n-kesteven.gov.uk

Follow this further

Built from North Kesteven's papers

What the report saysPro

Report to Executive Board

Environment Overview and Scrutiny Panel, North Kesteven District Council

Planning Gain for Health Provision Task and Finish Group

REPORT

Rev 1.1 22/01/19 I.C.

1 PREFACE

The Planning Gain for Health Provision Task and Finish Group was set up in 2018 under the Environment Overview and Scrutiny Panel of North Kesteven District Council. Group members were Cllr Ian Carrington (Chairman), Cllr Chris Goldson, Cllr Peter Lundgren and Cllr Mrs. Pat Woodman M.B.E. Officer support was provided by Chris Fox, Duncan James and Emily Wilcox. The Group heard evidence from a range of witnesses including North Kesteven management and officers and representatives from the health service. In addition, North Kesteven officers undertook extensive analytical work to provide valuable written evidence. The Group would like to thank all those who provided their time, expertise and technical knowledge to help us understand the complex subject area of our inquiry. In particular we would like to thank Sarah-Jane Mills, Chief Operating Officer of Lincolnshire West Clinical Commissioning Group and Jaqui Bunce, Programme Director of South West Lincolnshire Clinical Commissioning Group.

Cllr Ian Carrington (Chairman) January 2019

2 CONTENTS

Preface

1. Introduction & Desired Outcome 2. Key Findings 2.1 Planning Gain Take-up Rate 2.2 Monitoring & Management 2.3 System Constraints and Problems 2.4 Opportunities 3 Conclusions & Recommended Actions

Appendices Terms of Reference Methodology List of Witnesses

3 1. INTRODUCTION AND DESIRED OUTCOME 1.1 The Central Lincolnshire Local Plan adopted in 2017 provides for significant growth in North Kesteven in the period to 2036. The Plan makes detailed provision to ensure that infrastructure provision keeps pace with new housing and economic development, and contains a number of policies which specifically allow and encourage developer contributions (often known as ‘planning gain’) toward health provision. Such policies reflect overarching national regulation and guidance. 1.2 Concern has been expressed among elected members of North Kesteven District Council that these policies (and their equivalents in the previous Local Plan) may not be working sufficiently well. In particular members were concerned at the number of cases heard by the planning committee where no contribution was sought or a consultation response of ‘no comment’ was received from the health service. Members were also concerned at reports that due to resource limitations the NHS was routinely failing to seek contributions from entire categories of smaller qualifying developments. 1.3 Scrutiny of planning policy is a responsibility of the Environment Overview and Scrutiny Panel. In discussion its members felt that the concerns summarised above could potentially lead to avoidable failures to provide health service funding through planning gain. The Panel therefore set up the Planning Gain for Health Provision Task and Finish Group (TFG). The formal terms of reference of the TFG approved by the Panel were as follows: ‘to investigate the role of planning gain in achieving delivery of optimal health provision, and to explore ways in which outcomes can be improved’. 1.4 In essence the TFG sought answers to three questions i) Are we failing to collect ‘free money’ for the health service from developers? ii) How does the system actually work? iii) Can we make that system better?

Read every report as text, not just the decision

Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.

Papers for this item

Kept in our archive, download once signed in
PDF
Task and Finish Group report: Planning Gain for Health ProvisionReport 151 KB DownloadRead as text

At this meeting

Whole meeting

On this subject at North Kesteven

Search all
  1. Task and Finish Group report: Planning Gain for Health ProvisionThis decision
  2. Mental Health Task and Finish Group - Final ReportAgreed
  3. Garages Task and Finish Group - Draft ReportNoted
  4. Tree Task and Finish Group ReportDeferred
  5. Youth Unemployment Task and Finish GroupDecided
  6. Youth Unemployment Task and Finish Group (C&EOSP) RecommendationsDecided

More from North Kesteven Executive Board

All decisions
MeetingDecisionOutcome
3 Nov 2026 Proposed Private Hire and Hackney Carriage Fees and ChargesRecommended to Council: That approval be given to undertake a consultation process on the proposed draft licensing fe... Approved Open
3 Nov 2026 Review of The Private Sector Housing Enforcement PolicyThat the contents of the report and policy was noted. 2. That Executive Board approved the adoption of the new Privat... Noted Open
3 Nov 2026 NK Plan Quarter 2 Performance Report 2026/27That the key performance indicator progress in the NK Plan was approved. 2. That the Housing Regulatory Performance r... Approved Open
3 Nov 2026 Grantham Road Car ParkThat the appropriation of the part of the Grantham Road site shown on the plan at Appendix 1 from the Housing Revenue... Approved Open
3 Nov 2026 Medium Term Financial Strategy for 2027/28That the Medium Term Financial Strategy for 2027/28 to 2031/32 was approved. Approved Open

We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies