Resolved
That the use of Fixed Penalty Notices for breaches of the household waste duty of care be approved. 2. That the penalty fee for a Fixed Penalty Notice be set at £400 for the financial year 2019/20 with no reduction for early repayment, and that this fee be reviewed annually as part of the fee setting process. 3. That the Head of Environment and Public Protection be given discretion on the suitability of the use of a Fixed Penalty Notice for breaches of the household waste duty of care on a case by case basis and having regard to the Corporate Enforcement Policy. 1. That the use of Fixed Penalty Notices for breaches of the household waste duty of care be approved. 2. That the penalty fee for a Fixed Penalty Notice be set at £400 for the financial year 2019/20 with no reduction for early repayment, and that this fee be reviewed annually as part of the fee setting process. 3. That the Head of Environment and Public Protection be given discretion on the suitability of the use of a Fixed Penalty Notice for breaches of the household waste duty of care on a case by case basis and having regard to the Corporate Enforcement Policy. Reason for Decision • A Fixed Penalty Notice (FPN) can be issued as an alternative to prosecution. It allowed an individual to discharge liability for the duty of care offence by payment of a financial penalty instead of prosecution. Penalties should be set within the limits set out in legislation: Default penalty Minimum full penalty Maximum full penalty Minimum discounted penalty £200 £150 £400 £120 • Fees would be reviewed and published as part of the fees and charges review process. The changes in legislation would result in additional income, however at present how much is uncertain and therefore has not been factored into budgets. • This requirement related to a legal power under The Environmental Protection Act (1990) – Section 34 2A. • Waste enforcement was a priority area for the Environment and Public Protection Division and the Council was recognised for a proactive stance against fly tipping and the number of cases that we successfully pursue and prosecute. • It was proposed that each offence is considered on a case by case basis, having due regard to our Corporate Enforcement Policy, and that the decision as to whether to prosecute or offer to discharge the offence by way of fixed penalty sits with the Head of Environment and Public Protection as per current delegated authority. • Members discussed the process and timescales involved to decide an FPN, prosecution or caution in detail and noted that the Fixed Penalty Notices would provide an additional tool and more expedient way for Officers to carry out their role and demonstrate the Council’s serious approach to tackling the issue of fly tipping in the district. Alternative options considered and rejected (if any) 1. Set different penalty level – penalty for a significant offence needs to be at a high level for deterrent purposes. 2. Reduced penalty for early payment – penalty for a significant offence needs to be at a high level for deterrent purposes. 3. To not adopt the FPN provision – it is a useful tool to tackle fly-tipping and acts as an alternative to prosecution.