Resolved
RESOLVED that (1) the application for a Neighbourhood Area and Neighbourhood Forum for Sneinton is noted; (2) Committees finalised comments on the proposals will be compiled at a Working Group meeting, to which all Committee members will be invited by the Vice-Chair, and submitted as the Committee consultation response no later than 1 October 2014. NOTE: Subsequent to minute (2) above, the Working Group agreed the following as its response to the consultation: REPRESENTATION OF PLANNING COMMITTEE (Excluding Councillors Gibson and Khan, who have relevant interests) APPLICATION FOR SNEINTON NEIGHBOURHOOD FORUM AND AREA The Planning Committee wishes to make representations on the application for the designation of a Sneinton Neighbourhood Forum and Area. These representations are grouped under four headings, as follows: 1 Status of the Forum The status of the prospective Forum is unclear, in particular with regard to how far it is representative of the proposed area as a whole. There is no clarity about the purpose of the proposed Neighbourhood Plan, or what issues it is seeking to address. 2 Governance of Group Some individuals listed as members of the Forum have confirmed that they are not actually members. Not clear that adequate safeguards exist to prevent conflict of interest between Forum members and the proposed Neighbourhood Plan. 3 Boundary of Area and Strategic Sites The proposed area is very large to be considered a ‘neighbourhood’. The boundary appears to be arbitrary and area includes some areas that are not well related to Sneinton, such as the inclusion of the whole of Colwick woods, much of which relates to other neighbourhoods, such as Bakersfield. The proposed area includes a number of strategic sites pin the City Centre and elsewhere that are considered to be Strategic Sites (for instance the Bus Depot). The future of these sites will have City-wide implications, and it is important that their development is not fettered by local issues. Where the actual boundary sits will be important for matters such as highway/transport improvements, ie whether is it back of pavement, front of pavement or middle of the road. The boundary includes areas which serve a City-wide function, such as Sneinton Market. The whole City has an interest in the future of such areas. 4 Quality of Consultation Undertaken by Forum Several key local residents groups were unaware of the proposals, and had no previous contact with the prospective Neighbourhood Forum. Not clear that local businesses had been engaged in the process thus far. There is the potential for conflict of interest between the Creative Quarter and the Neighbourhood Plan. The prospective Forum claim to have circulated 2,000 leaflets within the area, however it is noted that the area contains considerably more addresses than this.