RESOLVED TO: (1) note the key findings from the KPMG audit of Grants and Returns report specific to the Housing Benefit Subsidy Claim 2015/16 and the Councils response; (2) invite Ian Roper back to a future meeting to update the Committee on progress made in error reduction; (3) thank John Maddison for his attendance and for presenting the report on Housing Benefit Subsidy Claim Qualification;
Word for word from the decision Nottingham published for this meeting.Source: committee.nottinghamcity.gov.uk
1.1It is recommended that Audit Committee note Sections 2.2, 2.5 and 2.8, the key findings from the KPMG Audit of Grants and Returns 2015/16 and the Councils improvement plan developed in conjunction with Northgate Public Services and Nottingham Revenues & Benefits Limited.
Background
2.1At Audit Committee in 24th February 2017 a report was presented by KPMG on their Annual Report of Grants and Returns 2015/16. The report explained their mandatory approach to the audit work and the requirement to re-visit error themes identified in previous years.
2.2The report highlighted increases in error rates compared to previous years audits, in total 606 cases were sample checked, with errors identified in 116 cases, an error rate of 19%. Whilst it is acknowledged that there has been an increase in the percentage of errors identified, the individual value and duration is much lower.
2.3Analysis of financial errors post audit and the impact of extrapolation shows the following:-
Financial Year Total Value of Qualification Qualification % Financial Subsidy Claim Value Accuracy Level 2013/14 £146m £1.215m 0.83% 99.17% 2014/15 £144.5m £1.060m 0.73% 99.27% 2015/16 £146m £870k 0.60% 99.4%
2.4KPMG acknowledge in their report that the error rates are not inconsistent with the findings of audits for other large unitary authorities.
2.5The theme of the errors identified relate to miscalculation of incomes for Earnings, Occupational Pensions, Tax Credits, Pension Credits, Childcare costs, Statutory Maternity Pay, Job Seekers Allowance and for effective dates used for New Claims, Change of Address and Extended Payments.
2.6In response, the Commercial Finance Contracts Management Team has so far met on two occasions with representatives from Northgate Public Services and Nottingham Revenues & Benefits Limited to formulate an action plan to address the key findings of the report.
2.7The action plan demonstrates the Partnerships commitment to continuous improvement, to ensure that quality is embedded and that staff are trained and receive appropriate feedback where errors are identified.
2.8The action plan incorporates the following:-
Case studies and Help-Sheets produced for all error types. These have been shared and discussed at colleague Team Meetings. Utilised regular 1-hour Thursday morning training sessions to work through error examples and exercises with teams. Desk-Aids being produced for identified themes and specific areas of risk. Preparing a business case to provide for more resources for quality checking to allow for in-year quality checks for known areas of risk to be undertaken, pre- submission of the HB Subsidy Claim.
2.9A number of additional initiatives to improve quality and accuracy have either been implemented since the 2015/16 subsidy claim audit or are in the process of being introduced. These improvements are based on intuitive software extracting and reading data from both Department for Work & Pensions and Her Majesty’s Revenues & Customs systems. The data is then automatically loaded into the core-processing system for recalculation using complex business rules and algorithms. This level of automation should remove many of the basic calculation errors and improved levels of accuracy.
3 BACKGROUND PAPERS OTHER THAN PUBLISHED WORKS OR THOSE DISCLOSING EXEMPT OR CONFIDENTIAL INFORMATION
3.1None
4 PUBLISHED DOCUMENTS REFERRED TO IN COMPILING THIS REPORT
4.1KPMG Annual Report on Grants & Returns 2015/16
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.