RESOLVED THAT: The Capital Asset Value for Amenity Trees method be approved for the future use of Planning and Arboricultural Officers as evidence of a tree’s assessed amenity value in tree-related disputes and negotiations. In accordance with Rule 7.3 of Part 4 of the Constitution, the Chair moved for the order of business to be altered and taken in the order as reflected in the minutes. RESOLVED THAT: The order of business be altered, accordingly.
Word for word from the decision Oadby and Wigston published for this meeting.Source: moderngov.oadby-wigston.gov.uk
CAVAT be approved for the future use of Planning and Arboricultural Officers as evidence of a tree’s assessed amenity value in tree related disputes and negotiations.
3. Information
3.1The CAVAT method of tree valuation uses a 5 step method to produce a value for a tree:
1. Basic Value: This is calculated by taking the trunk area (at 1.5m) and multiplying it by the national unit value factor (updated annually to track inflation)
2. Community Tree Index (CTI) Value:
a. The basic value is then adjusted dependant on the CTI (CTI is a measure of the relative population density potentially able to benefit from the tree, derived from Office of National Statistics (ONS) information.) These values range from 100% - 250% b. This value is then discounted by up to 60% dependant on accessibility.
3. Functional Value: The CTI Value is then decreased in increments of 10% depending on how well the tree is functioning biologically, Taking into account crown size and condition.
4. Adjusted Value: The functional value is then adjusted +/- 40% depending on:
a. Special amenity factors (historical, rarity, veteran status...) b. Appropriateness to the location
5. Full Value: The Adjusted value is then reduced (by upto 90%) depending on it Safe Life Expectancy (80+ years retains 100%, less than 5 years loses 90%).
This then gives the Full assessed amenity value of the tree. 3.2. Uses for OWBC:
1. Damage/Destruction of protected trees: A Tree Preservation Order or Conservation Area designation allows a LA to seek a fine from any person who damages a protected tree for the amenity lost. But how much do you fine? CAVAT gives that figure, for a damaged tree you can calculate the loss in value and for a tree that needs to be removed or has been destroyed the full value of the tree (up to £20000) can be fined.
2. Damage/Destruction of OWBC trees: As trees are the property of the landowner CAVAT can derive compensation costs for damage and destruction of council owned trees.
“We claimed over £9,000 from a firm that undertook unauthorised work to a council tree adjacent to the work site, specifically for the loss of CAVAT value.” - Jim Chambers, Islington Urban Forest Manager
3. Subsidence: CAVAT cannot be used as the sole reason to refuse the removal of a tree due to subsidence claims. But it can help to justify the losses to an area if a tree is removed and to help justify whether it is more cost effective to retain the tree and pursue other mitigation methods.
4. Reports and Statistics: CAVAT can be used to assess the value of an existing tree stock and to track the value added or taken away by tree planting, maintenance and removal of trees within the Borough.
‘If spending £1000 on tree planting equates to £10000 boost in amenity value of an area. Is it worth it?’
CAVAT is included into Ezytreev as a plugin and automatically calculates the values as you survey the trees. Once you have a representative value for one of your parks/wards/streets/etc it is an obvious evolution to present your findings to the appropriate portfolio holders on the value for insurance purposes. I know it transformed Walsall’s tree management very quickly.
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.