Resolved
That the information contained in the Late List be noted.
Planning Committee noted this item on Wednesday 16 February 2022. Below is the council's own wording, with the papers it was decided on.
Resolved
That the information contained in the Late List be noted.
PLANNING COMMITTEE 16th February 2022 Late information AGENDA DETAILS PAGES Pages 5 -36 AGENDA ITEM NUMBER: 6
SITE ADDRESS:
Land at Broadway Green Business Park, Foxdenton Lane, Chadderton
Additional Information:
Two additional representation have been received from both Lidl Great Britain Ltd and Tesco Stores Ltd. Rapleys on behalf of Lidl raise the following points (in summary) The full representations are on the website for review:
1. It has not been fully demonstrated that the proposal passes the sequential test as set out within Paragraph 87 and 88 of the National Planning Policy Framework (NPPF).
2. Given the two separate components which make up the application, it is necessary to give consideration to whether it is appropriate to disaggregate these elements for the purposes of undertaking the sequential test.
3. The outline element of the application is quite clearly flexible and open ended, in that there is no design for this part of the site and indeed, no end user or end use identified. As such, the two separate components of the scheme must be disaggregated for the purposes of the sequential test. At present, there is no assessment undertaken by the applicant which seeks to disaggregates the two uses.
4. Lidl do not agree that the outline element of the scheme will simply serve day to day sustenance needs. Whilst the Planning and Retail Statement submitted with the application states that the use will likely be a sandwich shop, bakery, drive-thru coffee shop or restaurant type facility, the actual end use remains open ended. Indeed, the applicants are seeking flexibility to allow the unit to trade within Use Classes E(a) Shop or E(b) Café / Restaurant. Martin Robeson Planning Practice (“MRRP”) on behalf of Tesco Stores Ltd raise the following objections (in summary):
1. Misapplication of the sequential test in respect of the commercial unit. Tesco do not agree with the sequential assessment of the commercial unit and conclude that alternative sites should be explored. They do not agree that the commercial unit should not been considered further in retail terms because it is considered that the facility will serve day to day needs.
2. Inappropriate judgements on retail impacts through references to retail ‘need’. The NPPF no longer requires an assessment of retail ‘need’ when bringing applications forward for proposals outside of town centres. Impact on “consumer choice” in the town centre (a consideration in paragraph 90 b of the NPPF) does not import the concept of need.
3. Uncertain Highways Impacts The proposed ‘flexible use’ unit could operate within any use under E(a) or E(b) (or in a combination of these uses should it be subdivided).
4. MRRP raise concerns about the existence of a fall-back position. MRRP conclude that the 2013 outline planning permission does not represent a “fall-back” use. The judgment of Lockhart Montgomery in R. v Secretary of State for the Environment and Havering London Borough Council, ex parte P.F. Ahern (London) Ltd. [1998] sets out a three- component fallback test: "First whether there is a fallback use, that is to say whether there is a lawful ability to undertake such a use; secondly, whether there is a likelihood or real prospect of such occurring. Thirdly if the answer to the second question is “yes” a comparison must be made between the proposed development and the fallback use". The extant permission for B-class uses does not permit retail development and thus does not create a lawful ability for the proposed use. The Officer’s Report applies the third stage of the Ahern test (comparing the impacts of the proposed development against the extant permission) in explaining “the proposal would have a lesser impact on nearby residents when compared with a B2 and/or B8 industrial type”. However, as the extant permission does not create a lawful ability to undertake the proposed retail use it is not a fall-back position and thus such a comparison is not relevant to make.
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
PDF |
Late ListReport | 355 KB | DownloadRead as text |
Follow Planning Committee at Oldham and we tell you when its next papers are published, before the meeting rather than after it.
| Meeting | Decision | Outcome | |
|---|---|---|---|
| 19 Aug 2026 | Election of ChairRESOLVED that Councillor Charters be elected Chair for the duration of the meeting. | Decided | Open |
| 19 Aug 2026 | Minutes of Previous MeetingRESOLVED that the minutes of the meeting held on 8 th July 2026 be approved as a correct record. | Approved | Open |
| 19 Aug 2026 | FUL/355703/26 - 45 - 49 Ripponden Road, Oldham, OL1 4EWThat the application be REFUSED for the following reason: “The proposed House in Multiple Occupation (HMO) would resu... | Refused | Open |
| 19 Aug 2026 | FUL/355368/25 - 74 Haigh Lane, Chadderton, Oldham, OL1 2TLThat the application be REFUSED for the reasons as set out in the report. NOTES: 1 . That Ward Members attended the m... | Refused | Open |
| 19 Aug 2026 | FUL/354250/25 - Street Bridge Inn, 230 Roman Road, Oldham, OL8 3QHThat the application be GRANTED subject to the conditions as outlined in the report, the amended condition 3 containe... | Approved | Open |
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.