CouncilMonitor
194 principal councils 228,996 meetings since 2000 2.8 million official papers archived Straight from each council's own publication system
Oldham Metropolitan Borough Council
Audit Committee, Thursday 26 March 2026 at 6.00pm

Counter Fraud Benchmarking

Noted Finance 1 paper

AI summaryOldham Audit Committee noted counter fraud report showing £297,720 in 2023/24 recoveries and a year on year rise in total financial outcomes to £448,786 in 2024/25.

AI summaryIn plain English

Written from the decision and the officer reportPDF Pro
OutcomeNotedCommittee considered and noted the counter fraud report
Money£297,720Oldham 2023/24 recoveries, 1 FTE
What happens nextOldham to lead 2025/26 benchmarkingFollow-up by Greater Manchester Fraud Investigation Group
Who it affectsOldham Council counter fraud workYear on year outcomes and benchmarking

What was decided

The Committee considered and noted the contents of the report on counter fraud benchmarking and year on year outcomes. Report P3, 5.1

Why

At the 14 January 2026 meeting, Members asked for comparative counter fraud and recovery data and a further breakdown of figures reported to the committee. Report 1.1

The report sets out 2023/24 benchmarking from North-West authorities, year on year data for Oldham from 2021/22 to 2024/25, and outcomes for April 2025 to end of February 2026. Report 1.2, 2.1, 3.1, 3.3

What happens next

No 2024/25 benchmarking exercise was carried out; Oldham will lead a follow-up for 2025/26 once accounts close, and results will return to the Committee. Report 2.5

The money

  • £297,720 Oldham recoveries/overpayments created in 2023/24 benchmarking Report 2.1, P11
  • £3,084,382 Total recoveries across all 13 North-West authorities in 2023/24 benchmarking Report 2.1, P11
  • £408,478 Oldham total financial outcomes from counter fraud 2021/22 Report 3.1, P19
  • £312,060 Oldham total financial outcomes from counter fraud 2022/23 Report 3.1, P19
  • £297,720 Oldham total financial outcomes from counter fraud 2023/24 Report 3.1, P19
  • £448,786 Oldham total financial outcomes from counter fraud 2024/25 Report 3.1, P19
  • £269,871.24 Oldham total financial outcomes from counter fraud, April 2025 to end of February 2026 Report 3.3, P22
  • £88,637.76 Oldham fraud and error overpayments in corporate cases, April 2025 to end of February 2026 Report 3.3, P22, P23

Options considered

  • Chosen: Accept and note the contents of the report. Preferred option recommended by officers Report P26, 5.1
  • Rejected: Decline to accept and note the report and suggest an alternative approach Report P26

Implications

  • Staffing: Oldham does not employ any Officers in a Fraud Investigator role; its resource is 1 FTE covering both direct investigation and managerial or strategic work, and staffing remained stable from 2021/22 to 2024/25. Report 2.2, 3.2
  • Risk: The 2025/26 Audit and Counter Fraud Plan and project terms of reference were prepared using a risk-based approach. Report 11.1
  • Equalities: No Equality Impact Assessment has been completed for this report. Report 17.1

Who and where

  • Council Tax Reduction claimants in Oldham, where 84 CTR cases were amended following investigation between April 2025 and the end of February 2026 Report 3.3, P22
  • Staff and suppliers, with cases including Credit Card Payment fraud, Duplicate Payments, Direct Payment Misuse, and Staff Abuse of Position identified in the same period Report P23

Timeline

  • 2021/22 to 2024/25: Year on year counter fraud outcomes for Oldham Report 3.1, P17, P18, P19
  • 2023/24: Latest available North-West authority benchmarking data Report 2.1, P11
  • April 2025 to the end of February 2026: Breakdown of counter fraud outcomes for 2025/26 to date Report 3.3, P22, P23
  • 2025/26: Follow-up benchmarking exercise to be led by Oldham after year end Report 2.5
  • 14 January 2026: Audit Committee asked for comparative counter fraud and recovery data Report 1.1
  • 26 March 2026: Audit Committee noted the counter fraud benchmarking report Report 5.1

Plain English for the jargon

  • CTR: Council Tax Reduction, a means-tested discount on council tax bills.
  • HB: Housing Benefit, a means-tested benefit to help with rent.
  • NFI: National Fraud Initiative, a data matching exercise run by the Cabinet Office to detect fraud.
  • FTE: Full Time Equivalent, a unit measuring staff workload on the basis of one full-time worker.
What was decided, why, and what happens next

Pro reads every officer report for you and explains each decision in plain English: the money, the options, the risks, the timeline, each with the paragraph it came from.

Written by AI from the council's published papers. AI can get things wrong: the council's own wording below is the record.Report a problem
Item8

Resolved

That the Committee considered the contents of the report and noted the report.
Word for word from the decision Oldham published for this meeting. Source: committees.oldham.gov.uk

Follow this further

Built from Oldham's papers

What the report saysPro

Report to Audit Committee

Executive summary

This report summarises:

 The latest available benchmarking data from participating North-West Authorities.  Year on year counter fraud figures for Oldham.  A breakdown of counter fraud outcomes from April 2025 to the end of February 2026.

Recommendation

Members are requested to consider the contents of the report. Audit Committee 26 March 2026

Counter-fraud outcomes and benchmarking data

Background

1.1At the Audit Committee’s meeting of 14 January 2026, Members requested comparative data on counter fraud and recovery outcomes and further breakdown of the figures reported to the committee.

1.2The main content of this report is structured as follows:

This report summarises:

Section 2 - The latest available benchmarking data from participating North-West Authorities. Section 3 - Year on year counter fraud figures for Oldham and a breakdown of outcomes from April 2025 to the end of February 2026.

2. 2023/24 Benchmarking data from participating North-West Authorities

2.1The latest available benchmarking data from 2023/24, from participating North-West Authorities, is shown in the table below.

Authority Recoveries/Overpayments Created FTE £ Per FTE Blackpool £192,690 3 £64,230 Bury £173,289 3.8 £45,602 Fylde £99,132 1 £99,132 Lancaster £367,006 2 £183,503 Oldham £297,720 1 £297,720 Preston £106,773 2.3 £46,423 Rochdale £179,794 4 £44,949 Rossendale £85,784 1 £85,784 Salford £64,486 3 £21,495 Tameside £217,700 2 £108,850 Trafford £351,885 2.5 £140,754 Warrington £687,116 3 £229,039 Wigan £261,007 2 £130,504 Total £3,084,382

2.2The original benchmarking questionnaire asked for FTE staffing numbers of Fraud Investigators employed by each Authority. Oldham does not currently employ any Officers in a Fraud Investigator role (or equivalent). Oldham’s fraud investigation resource currently comprises 1 FTE Officer who undertakes a range of fraud investigation work, both directly and in a managerial/strategic capacity, on behalf of the Audit and Counter Fraud Service. To enable a meaningful comparison of the data on a per FTE basis, we have added one FTE to all respondents’ data (including Oldham) to reflect managerial and other fraud related work undertaken. 2.3 Review of the data does not appear to suggest any direct correlation between the number of staff employed and the total recoveries identified. Nor is there any obvious correlation on a per FTE basis.

2.4Warrington Council reported the highest total recoveries and Salford Council the lowest. Both Councils employed an equivalent number of staff. At the time of comparison Warrington and Salford shared (jointly employed) an experienced Chief Internal Auditor, yet achieved significantly different outcomes.

2.5No subsequent benchmarking exercise was undertaken for 2024/25. It has been agreed at the Greater Manchester Fraud Investigation Group that Oldham will lead on a follow up exercise for 2025/26 following the closure of accounts for the year. Results from this exercise will be brought back to the Committee in due course.

3 Year on year results and breakdown of results

3.1Year on year comparative outcomes between 2021/22 and 2024/25 are shown in the table below:

Counter Fraud Team - Comparative Performance Data 2021/22 to 2024/25 Counter Fraud Team: 2021/22 2022/23 2023/24 2024/25

Corporate Cases - Positive Results 114 114 99 165

Read every report as text, not just the decision

Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.

Papers for this item

Kept in our archive, download once signed in
PDF
Counter Fraud BenchmarkingReport 183 KB DownloadRead as text

At this meeting

Whole meeting

Who was there

10 of 28 attended
SA
Sam Al-HamdaniCommittee Member, apologies, sent representative
NA
Naseem AslamCommittee Member, present
AB
Andrew BloorOfficer, in attendance
AB
Alex BougatefOfficer, in attendance
ZC
Zahid Chauhan OBECommittee Member, apologies, sent representative
NC
Naveed ChowhanCommittee Member, absent
JD
Julie DanielsOfficer, in attendance
ED
Eleanor DevlinPublic, in attendance
SG
Sheila GararaOfficer, in attendance
KG
Kamran GhafoorCommittee Member, absent
MG
Matthew GrattonOfficer, in attendance
SG
Stuart GreenIndependent Member, apologies

All 28 on the meeting page

On this subject at Oldham

Search all
  1. Counter Fraud BenchmarkingThis decision
  2. Q4 2025/26 and Q1 2026/27 Internal Audit and Counter Fraud Progress ReportApproved
  3. 2026/27 Internal Audit and Counter Fraud PlanApproved
  4. Quarter 2 - 2025/26: Internal Audit and Counter Fraud Progress ReportDecided
  5. Counter Fraud and Corruption Policies and ProceduresNoted
  6. 2025/26 Internal Audit and Counter Fraud PlanApproved

More from Oldham Audit Committee

All decisions
MeetingDecisionOutcome
22 Jul 2026 MinutesThat the of the meeting of the Audit Committee, held 26 th Manch 2026, be approved as a correct and the accompanying ... Approved Open
22 Jul 2026 Members' Allowances UpdateThat the Audit Committee notes ... view the full minutes text for item 6. Decided Open
22 Jul 2026 Audit Strategy MemorandumThat the report be noted. Noted Open
22 Jul 2026 Draft 2025/26 Annual Statement of AccountsThat the Council’s draft Statement of Accounts for 2025/26, be noted. Noted Open
22 Jul 2026 Treasury Management Review 2025/26That the Audit Committee notes and endorses the Treasury Management Outturn report and the Treasury Management activi... Decided Open

We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies