CouncilMonitor
194 principal councils 228,996 meetings since 2000 2.8 million official papers archived Straight from each council's own publication system
Portsmouth City Council
Resources, Thursday 13 October 2016 at 10.00am

CIPFA Value for Money Comparisons.

Noted Committee 2 papers

Resources noted this item on Thursday 13 October 2016. Below is the council's own wording, with the papers it was decided on.

Item14

Resolved

DECISION: The Cabinet Member (a) Noted the information in the report and Appendix 1 and (b) Considered if any further information is required.
Word for word from the decision Portsmouth published for this meeting. Source: democracy.portsmouth.gov.uk

Follow this further

Built from Portsmouth's papers

What the report saysPro

Report to Resources

Purpose of report

1.1The purpose of this report is to inform the Cabinet Member for Resources of Portsmouth's relative position on a number of indicators according to CIPFA's VFM toolkit; and to seek consideration of whether any further information is required.

Recommendations

2.1It is recommended that the Cabinet Member for Resources:

a) Notes the information in the report and Appendix 1; b) Considers if any further information is required.

Reasons for recommendations

3.1On an annual basis, CIPFA (the public sector finance body) issue a "toolkit" which pulls together statutory (and some voluntary) returns on organisational costs and performance, in order to provide a high-level view on these dimensions relative to other authorities, and relative to each other. This information can be filtered in a number of ways (by performance indicator, by service, and by comparator group). This is then used to derive a judgement on the relative VFM being provided in a given service area.

3.2There are significant limitations and caveats on the data and its use. There is an issue about the robustness of what is included. It is acknowledged that financial returns used in the toolkit (RA and RO forms), can include some inaccuracies. The “service” groupings identified by CIPFA are areas of activity that do not necessary correlate to that PCC groups these areas into service units. There are also omissions, most notably of specific reference to a number of back-office functions (HR, Legal, Finance, IT, policy services, audit, customer service, democratic services, communications for example). This is because 1 www.portsmouth.gov.uk “corporate overheads” are apportioned across the costs of service provision – and overheads within services are too (so service based support staff aren’t identified). This is the same for all authorities, but we also know that apportionment policies vary –so there is a built in element of comparing apples and pears. There are also some choices of indicators of performance that might cause us concern. Finally, there are some concerns about timeliness, and that comparisons are being made against budgets that have since been significantly reduced.

3.3Nonetheless, in terms of providing an overview of areas of cost in the organisation, and the sort of performance resulting, the CIPFA toolkit can still provide a starting point for discussion of where we might want to look in more detail at costs. The findings are not absolute, and further investigation must of course include a rigorous testing of the underlying data and assumptions.

4. Conclusions from the information

4.1The attached Appendix A sets out the headlines findings from the toolkit. A high level analysis of Portsmouth's relative positions using the new data has been carried out. This compares cost and performance scores (where available) to that of a group of statistical neighbours, and provides a relative percentile ranking for the two dimensions (where a high percentile is "good" for performance, and "bad" for cost). This initial analysis does suggest that there are areas where we have comparatively high costs compared with others; and some areas where our costs are comparatively low.

4.2The appendix also shows what the projected cost position is for the following year of the toolkit (actually the last year of operation) based on information about 15/16 budgets supplied in the RA forms.

4.3The Cabinet Member for Resources is asked to consider this information, and whether any further information or analysis is required, including from any other sources.

4.4The Cabinet Member is also asked to consider whether updates should be presented when further toolkit releases are issued.

5. Equality impact assessment (EIA)

Read every report as text, not just the decision

Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.

Papers for this item

Kept in our archive, download once signed in
PDF
CIPFA Value for Money Comparisons.Report 180 KB DownloadRead as text
PDF
VFM appendix 1Appendix 380 KB Download

At this meeting

Whole meeting

Who was there

4 of 4 attended
LM
Councillor Lee MasonCabinet Member, present
CG
Councillor Colin GallowayOpposition spokesperson, present
HM
Councillor Hugh MasonOpposition spokesperson, present
YC
Councillor Yahiya ChowdhuryOpposition spokesperson, present

More from Portsmouth Resources

All decisions
MeetingDecisionOutcome
27 Jan 2020 International Relationship StrategyThe Cabinet Member for Resources (1) Adopts this proposed International Relationship Strategy 2020 - 2025. (2) Agrees... Approved Open
22 Jan 2019 Provision of Community FuneralsDECISION: The Cabinet Member (1) Approved the manner in which community funerals are delivered, as outlined in Sectio... Approved Open
20 Dec 2018 Transfer of Properties to Portsmouth Community Housing TrustDECISION: that the Cabinet Member for Resources approved the following: (1) That 1-3 Angerstein Road be transferred b... Approved Open
8 Mar 2018 Volunteering Strategy 2018-2021DECISION: The Cabinet Member for Resources gave approval to implement the Volunteering Strategy attached as appendix ... Approved Open
8 Mar 2018 City Priority StandardDECISION: The Cabinet Member for Resources (1) Approved the Portsmouth (the Standard) (2) Requested that the Director... Approved Open

We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies