Item6
Resolved
That we ( i ) note the information provided in the report on our Committee’s role since the introduction of modified governance arrangements in May 2013; and (ii) refer the following comments to Cabinet to assist its review of those arrangements: (a) concern that effective Scrutiny had suffered with the reduction in the number of Working Groups from 12 to 3 per annum, given the very effective cross-cutting scrutiny role and policy making undertaken by the Working Groups (b) concern that the limited number of External Scrutiny Panel meetings was not enabling sufficient opportunities to monitor and keep pressure upon public transport providers (c) greater advance profiling of outside body attendance at External Scrutiny Panels should be given in order to inform and engage more Members and enable greater attendance at meetings (d) concern that there was a need for the former Cycling Liaison Group and former Public Transport Liaison Group to be re-established, given their specific roles and success in undertaking such (e) concern that, with Service Committees being constrained in only considering those reports submitted to the Executive, there needed to be more reports submitted to cover all Services and much earlier engagement with Cabinet Members in the reporting process (f) concern that too much power remained in the hands of the nine Cabinet Members and a more effective way was needed in order to fully utilise the input of all Members, particularly given the impact of Budget cuts in future years (g) the culture of governance was important in terms of good leadership to encourage Cabinet Members to openly engage in cross-party discussion in developing policies and ideas (h) concern that the present arrangements placed too much emphasis upon scrutinising decisions rather than upon the Services themselves.
Word for word from the decision Redbridge published for this meeting.
Source: moderngov.redbridge.gov.uk