That the application be deferred for further negotiation and to go back to Committee within 3 months. ([name removed] spoke in favour of the above application. [name removed] spoke against the above application. Cllr D Birtwhistle was given permission to speak on the above application).
Word for word from the decision Ribble Valley published for this meeting.Source: democracy.ribblevalley.gov.uk
ERECTION OF A BALL STOP SAFETY FENCE ON THE 1ST FAIRWAY AT CLITHEROE GOLF CLUB ON LAND ADJACENT TO HOUSING ON ELBOW WOOD DRIVE, BARROW.
CONSULTEE RESPONSES/ REPRESENTATIONS MADE:
TOWN COUNCIL: No comments received at time of preparing this report
ADDITIONAL REPRESENTATIONS:
1 letter of support and in favour of safety measures but would like to see the fence extended towards the first tee.
6 letters of objection raising the following issues: Visual impact of the netting Harm to wildlife such as bird and bats Loss of view and reduce value of properties. Fence given its height and location would be oppressive and intrusive Impact on mental health of residents due to reduction in sunlight. Consider the fence would be ineffective and better solutions such as tee relocation and angling of fence towards fairway.
1. Site Description and Surrounding Area
1.1The fence is located adjacent to the existing track within the golf club and adjacent to the gardens of 7,9,11 and 15 Elbow Wood Drive Barrow.
2. Proposed Development for which consent is sought
2.1This application seeks detailed consent for the erection of a 6 metre high ball stop safety net for a length of 90 metres. The fence would have galvanised steel poles every 5 metres. The fence is open for the first 2 metres with the top 4 metres to have green netting and stainless steel cables.
3. Relevant Planning History
None specific to this part of the site.
4. Relevant Policies
Ribble Valley Core Strategy Policy DMG1 – General Considerations
5. Assessment of Proposed Development
5.1A justification statement has been submitted with this application but as the principle use as a golf course has been established the main issues to consider relate to visual impact, residential amenity and habitat matters.
5.2Design:
5.2.1 In relation to the design it is considered that the fencing is of an appropriate appearance and of a design used for most types of golf ball netting. The colour of the netting has been changed from black to green to reduce the impact and relate better to the immediate landscape.
5.3Visual:
5.3.1 It is evident that a fence measuring 90m long and 6 m high would have some visual impact but this has a localised impact on the users of the golf club and immediate residents. There is no long distant impact and views of the netting would be partially screened by existing vegetation. 5.4 Wildlife/Habitat:
5.4.1 Concerns have been expressed in relation to impact on wildlife and in particular bats and birds. The Councils countryside officer in consultation with an ecologist has confirmed that the fencing would not have any serious impact on such issues. It is important that the fence is tort to reduce any impact on the movement of bats.
5.5Residential Amenity/ Noise:
5.5.1 The issues in relation to residential amenity are impact on light and the oppressive nature of the fencing. It is considered that the fencing is a sufficient distance away not to have an oppressive impact on the properties facing towards the net and the openness of the netting will not result in a harmful loss of light.
6. Other issues
6.1Concern has been raised about the effectiveness of the netting and that other better options such as relocation of the first tee would be more effective. The comments are noted but the application needs to be determined as submitted. It is evident that the fencing will inevitable reduce the risk of errant golf balls and go some way to safeguard the residents and their properties from errant golf balls. The devaluation of properties and loss of view are not material planning considerations.
RECOMMENDED: That the application be APPROVED subject to the following conditions:
1. The development must be begun not later than the expiration of three years beginning with the date of this permission.
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.