That the application be minded to refuse and be taken back to a future Committee with appropriate reasons relating to: Policy DMB3: undermining the character, quality and visual amenities of the area by virtue of its scale, siting materials and design, Policy EN2: the development is not in keeping with the character of the landscape in respect of its scale, The NPPF para 180- proliferation of domestic paraphernalia and environmental impact. (Head of Planning advised para 180 and Environmental impact may not be appropriate ) (Simon Pemberton spoke in favour of the above application. Stella Rosthorn spoke against the above application)
Word for word from the decision Ribble Valley published for this meeting.Source: democracy.ribblevalley.gov.uk
APPLICATION REF: 3/2021/0720 GRID REF: SD 382579 451917 DEVELOPMENT DESCRIPTION: CHANGE OF USE OF LAND TO FORM AN EXTENSION OF RIBBLE VALLEY COUNTRY AND LEISURE PARK TO FACILITATE AN ADDITIONAL 62 STATIC CARAVAN PITCHES (ALLOWING A TOTAL OF 387 PITCHES ACROSS THE PARK), ASSOCIATED HIGHWAY WORKS, SEWAGE TREATMENT PLANT AND PUMPING STATION, IMPROVEMENTS TO THE EXISTING OPEN SPACE AND THE CREATION OF ADDITIONAL OPEN SPACE, LANDSCAPING AND OTHER ASSOCIATED WORKS AT TWYN GHYLL CARAVAN SITE, SETTLE LANE, PAYTHORNE, BB7 4JD CONSULTEE RESPONSES/ REPRESENTATIONS MADE:
PARISH COUNCIL:
Paythorne Parish Council wishes to object to the application a detailed letter has been submitted and the main areas of concerns raised are in relation to:
• Highway safety, access, deliveries. • Impact on ecology no biodiversity net gain • Detrimental visual impact on the surrounding countryside and landscape.
Following reconsultation, the Parish Council do not consider that the revised scheme adequately addresses their concerns and that the development will still have an unacceptable impact.
ENVIRONMENT DIRECTORATE (COUNTY SURVEYOR):
The Highways Development Control Section has raised no objection to the proposal subject to the imposition of technical conditions which are discussed further in the report.
WOODLAND TRUST:
Object:
• Detrimental impact to ancient woodland – potential damage. • Damage to plantations on ancient woodland sites. • Non-suitable buffer zone. • Increasing amount of pollution including dust, light. • Disturbance to wildlife from traffic and visitors. • Changing landscape character of area. • Increasing damaging activities like fly-tipping and domestic pets.
The Woodland Trust has been consulted on the revised scheme but at the time of writing the report have not provided further comments.
CAMPAIGN TO PROTECT RURAL ENGLAND:
Object:
• Too much farmland is being lost for development. • Contrary to adopted local plan policy DMB3 (as undermines character and visual amenity of area). • Levels of traffic would be too high – noise and air pollution issues. • Impact on site ecology. • Not enough amenities in Paythorne.
UNITED UTILITIES:
• Concerns around water supply - Extending of water mains needed. • Sustainable draining of surface water. • No wastewater assets in the area. LANCASHIRE FIRE AND RESCUE:
• Scheme fully meets all the requirements of Building Regulations Approved Document B, Part B5 ‘Access and Facilities for the Fire Service’
ADDITIONAL REPRESENTATIONS:
65 Objections have been received.
Issues of Concern:
Social/Community:
• Dominate the hamlet and surrounding countryside - character • Noise pollution from caravan site – will be exacerbated further with extension • Hamlet has a lack of facilities to accommodate more tourists • Increased risk to privacy and security for Paythorne residents • Psychological distress from increased traffic • Increased disruption to local businesses • Extra demand on power services • No immediate community benefit
Highways:
• Safety issues for pedestrians - Lack of walkways, street-lighting, no road markings or street signage • Rising carbon emissions from increased site traffic • Heavy traffic will erode local roads during construction • Traffic congestion • Air Pollution from increased car use • Damage to the Grade II historically significant bridge by HGVs delivering caravans • Parking issues
Environmental:
• Visible from the main road – especially during winter months when leaves won’t conceal • Detrimental impact on wildlife (deer, protected bats, buzzards, rare barn owls) • Damage to Green Belt • Damage to heritage value of area (Twyn Ghyll Heritage Woodland) • Detrimental effect on trees and hedgerows • No evidence supplied that trees have ash die back • Park Leisure currently has a lack of regard to PRoW • Effect on listed buildings and scheduled ancient monuments • Poor water pressure currently • Increased risk of flooding
Other:
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.