CouncilMonitor
194 principal councils 228,996 meetings since 2000 2.8 million official papers archived Straight from each council's own publication system
Ribble Valley Borough Council
Planning and Development, Thursday 10 March 2022 at 6.30pm

Planning Application 3/2021/1118 - Land rear of Former Punch Bowl, Hurst Green

Refused Planning 1 paper

Planning and Development refused this item on Thursday 10 March 2022. Below is the council's own wording, with the papers it was decided on.

Item725

Resolved

RESOLVED that the application be refused for the following reasons: 1. The proposed development is harmful to the setting of the listed building because it is unduly prominent, incongruous, conspicuous, discordant and dominant in location, scale, form and materials. This is contrary to Key Statement EN5 and Policy DME4 and DMG1 of the Ribble Valley Core Strategy. 2. The proposed development is harmful to the character of the open countryside in the immediate setting of the Forest of Bowland AONB because it is unduly prominent, incongruous, conspicuous and discordant in the landscape. This is contrary to Key Statement EN2 and Policy DMG2 and DMG1 of the Ribble Valley Core Strategy.
Word for word from the decision Ribble Valley published for this meeting. Source: democracy.ribblevalley.gov.uk

Follow this further

Built from Ribble Valley's papers

What the report saysPro

Report to Planning and Development

APPLICATION REF: 3/2021/1118

GRID REF: SD 367396 437862

DEVELOPMENT DESCRIPTION:

CHANGE OF USE OF LAND TO CREATE A 15 PITCH STATIC CARAVAN HOLIDAY PARK AT LAND TO THE REAR OF THE FORMER PUNCH BOWL INN LONGRIDGE ROAD HURST GREEN.

CONSULTEE RESPONSES/ REPRESENTATIONS MADE:

PARISH COUNCIL:

Object because of over-development of the site, highway safety, demolition of the Punch Bowl as a grade two listed building, visual amenity (no screening; obtrusive; design of static caravans) and harm to AONB. Can no longer piggy-back a holiday park on the back of an existing hospitality venue. LCC HIGHWAYS:

No objection subject to conditions (implementation of access arrangements; visibility splay; surfacing; implementation of parking and turning facilities; preventing site materials on public highway).

LANCASHIRE FIRE AND RESCUE SERVICE:

Recommendations to applicant.

ENVIRONMENT AGENCY:

No objection. Informatives suggested.

LANCASHIRE LOCAL LEAD FLOOD AUTHORITY:

No comment.

UNITED UTILITIES:

Informatives suggested.

ADDITIONAL REPRESENTATIONS:

11 letters of objection have been received which make the following points:

 Demolition of listed building;  Not in-keeping with a re-built Punch Bowl Inn;  Highway safety;  Visual amenity, no longer screened; intrusive;  Site not accurately marked;  Overdevelopment;  Detached from Hurst Green;  Boundary of AONB and adjoining public footpath – design and density do not conserve  landscape or reflect local distinctiveness, vernacular style, scale, features and building  materials;  Ensure holiday homes are not occupied permanently

1. Site Description and Surrounding Area

1.1As Members are aware the application site forms part of the curtilage of the former Punch Bowl Inn (listed Grade II) which was demolished in 2021. Whilst the component materials of the building are retained in situ the demolition of the building has resulted in the loss of an important heritage asset recognised by its listed status. The demolition is subject to separate legal action.

1.2The site is within open countryside immediately adjacent the Forest of Bowland Area of Outstanding Natural Beauty.

1.3The site is at a nodal point in respect to the public rights of way network. Public footpath FP13 runs north-south following the west site boundary (and coinciding with the tree-lined Bailey Brook). Bridleway BW5 and footpath FP15 (within the AONB) run north-south and end at the Longridge Road near to the site.

1.4Trees lining the Bailey Brook are an Ancient Woodland (Ribble Valley Core Strategy DME1).

2. Proposed Development for which consent is sought

2.1Planning permission is sought for change of use of the Punch Bowl curtilage to a 15 pitch static caravan holiday park. The static caravans are arranged in a semi-circle around the south of the listed building.

2.2Two static caravan types are proposed – Eight 12.8m length x 5.8m width and seven 12.8m length x 4m width. The agent has confirmed that the static caravans will be raised on average 0.75m off the ground (dependant on site contours) and will measure 2.7m to the eaves and 3.2m to the ridge from decking level (land levels would be secured by condition in the event of a positive recommendation). Walls – timber cladding/’timber effect boarding’; roof – ‘tile effect’; windows and doors – upvc.

3. Relevant Planning History

3/2019/0470- Removal of unsafe roof and replace with new truss and slate roof. Removal of defective render to assess the quality of stonework beneath. If good quality stonework to be cleaned and kept. If not suitable rendered areas to renewed with K render. Refused 24/03/2020.

3/2019/0260- Application for the discharge of condition 3 (details of the Proposed Elevations of the South Elevation and First Floor Plan), 4 (storage area), 5 (revised parking layout), 6 (Heritage Statement), 7 (specifications of proposed windows and doors including elevations cross - sections, glazing type, opening mechanism and surface finish) and 8 (phasing plan) from planning permission 3/2018/0363.

Read every report as text, not just the decision

Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.

Papers for this item

Kept in our archive, download once signed in
PDF
Planning Application 3/2021/1118: Land rear of Former Punch Bowl, Hurst GreenAppendix 503 KB DownloadRead as text

At this meeting

Whole meeting

Who was there

14 of 23 attended
AB
Councillor Alison BrownChair, present
IB
Councillor Ian BrownCommittee Member, present
SB
Councillor Stella Brunskill JPCommittee Member, present
R(
Councillor Robert (Bob) BullerCommittee Member, present
SC
Councillor Stuart CarefootCommittee Member, present
JC
Councillor Judith ClarkVice-Chair, present
LE
Councillor Louise EdgeCommittee Member, present
MF
Councillor Mark FrenchCommittee Member, present
BH
Councillor Brian HoldenCommittee Member, present
KH
Councillor Kevin Horkin MBECommittee Member, apologies
AH
Councillor Angeline HumphreysCommittee Member, present
SO
Councillor Simon O'RourkeCommittee Member, present

All 23 on the meeting page

On this subject at Ribble Valley

Search all
  1. Planning Application 3/2021/1118 - Land rear of Former Punch Bowl, Hurst GreenThis decision
  2. Local Validation Checklist for Planning ApplicationsApproved
  3. Local Validation Checklist for Planning ApplicationsAgreed
  4. Planning Application 3/2022/0879 - Land South of Ludlow Road, Clitheroe, BB7 2RJDeferred
  5. Planning Application 3/2022/0637 - Keepers Cottage, Northcote Road, Old Langho, BB6 8DBApproved
  6. Planning Application 3/2022/0857 - Croasdale Farm, 1 Whinney Lane, Langho, BB6 8DQApproved

More from Ribble Valley Planning and Development

All decisions
MeetingDecisionOutcome
27 Aug 2026 3/2025/0801 - Land to east of Salesbury View WilpshireRESOLVED THAT COMMITTEE: REFUSE PLANNING PERMISSION for the following reasons: 1. The proposed development would be o... Refused Open
27 Aug 2026 3/2022/0317 - Land at Higher Standen Farm and Part Littlemoor Farm ClitheroeRESOLVED THAT COMMITTEE: GRANT planning permission subject to the following condition(s): 1. Unless explicitly requir... Approved Open
27 Aug 2026 3/2026/0442 - Castle Museum Clitheroe Castle Castlegate Clitheroe BB7 1AZRESOLVED THAT COMMITTEE: GRANT planning permission subject to the following condition(s): The development hereby perm... Approved Open
27 Aug 2026 3/2025/0997 - Land off Henthorn Road Clitheroe BB7 3BYRESOLVED THAT COMMITTEE: Application deferred to enable an alternative access directly off Henthorn Road to serve the... Deferred Open
27 Aug 2026 3/2026/0230 - Land to the south of Ribblesdale Primary School west and north of Higher Standen DriveRESOLVED THAT COMMITTEE: DEFER AND DELEGATE to the Director of Economic Development and Planning for approval subject... Deferred Open

We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies