CouncilMonitor
194 principal councils 228,996 meetings since 2000 2.8 million official papers archived Straight from each council's own publication system
Ribble Valley Borough Council
Planning and Development, Thursday 24 August 2023 at 6.30pm

3/2023/0447 - Land off Hammond Drive Read BB12 7RE

Refused Planning 1 paper

Planning and Development refused this item on Thursday 24 August 2023. Below is the council's own wording, with the papers it was decided on.

Item210

Resolved

RESOLVED THAT COMMITTEE: Refused planning permission for the following reasons: 1.The proposal would lead to the creation of a new residential dwelling outside of the settlement without sufficient justification insofar that it has not been adequately demonstrated that the proposal would meet any of the exception criteria including meeting a local housing need or providing regeneration benefits. The proposal therefore fails to accord with Key Statement DS1 and DS2 and policies DMG2 and DMH3 of the Ribble Valley Core Strategy 2008 – 2028. 2. The proposal would result in a large, dominant, dwellinghouse of modern design and materials which would have a visually harmful and urbanising impact upon the rural character of the area. It would also have a harmful impact on the simple architecture and traditional character and appearance of the Grade II* Listed Read Hall and its associated Parkland, the Grade II Listed Ice House and a number of non-designated heritage assets and their settings. Any public benefits from the development do not outweigh this less than substantial harm. The proposal therefore is contrary to the Planning (Listed Building and Conservation Area) Act 1990, the National Planning Policy Framework and Key Statement EN5 and Policies DMG1, DME2 and DME4 of the Ribble Valley Core Strategy 2008 - 2028. 3. The proposal would result in a large, dominant, dwellinghouse close to historic woodland and fails to demonstrate that the proposed dwelling and its surrounding large expanse of hard surfacing can be accommodated without resulting in an adverse impact on the root protection area of the historic woodland and in particular Trees T1 and T2. Therefore, the proposal is contrary to Policies DME1 and DME2 of the Ribble Valley Core Strategy 2008 – 2028. 4. The proposal would result in an elevated terraced area in close proximity to the neighbouring property to the west, known as The Stables. This would result in an unacceptable impact on the residential amenity of the occupiers of this neighbouring because of adverse levels of overlooking and loss of privacy that would be afforded. Therefore the proposal is contrary to Policy DMG1 of the Ribble Valley Core Strategy 2008 – 2028.
Word for word from the decision Ribble Valley published for this meeting. Source: democracy.ribblevalley.gov.uk

Follow this further

Built from Ribble Valley's papers

What the report saysPro

Report to Planning and Development

RECOMMENDATION FOR PLANNING AND DEVELOPMENT COMMITTEE

REFUSAL

DATE: 24 AUGUST 2023 REF: KH CHECKED BY: LH

APPLICATION REF: 3/2023/0447

GRID REF: SD 375744 434938

DEVELOPMENT DESCRIPTION:

PROPOSED NEW DWELLING AT LAND OFF HAMMOND DRIVE, READ CONSULTEE RESPONSES/ REPRESENTATIONS MADE:

READ PARISH COUNCIL:

No response.

LANCASHIRE COUNTY COUNCIL (LOCAL HIGHWAY AUTHORITY):

No objection - the proposed development would not have a significant impact on highway safety, capacity or amenity in the immediate vicinity of the site.

An adequate level of off-road parking has been provided and an electric vehicle charging point will be provided to improve the site’s sustainability.

HISTORIC ENGLAND:

Do not wish to offer any advice and suggest views are sought from the Council’s specialist conservation and archaeological advisers.

LANCASHIRE ARCHAEOLOGICAL ADVISORY SERVICE:

The proposals lie within the limits of Read Park, an early 19th century landscape park, recorded as a non-designated heritage asset on the Lancashire Historic Environment Record, PRN37695.

The proposed new dwelling is not considered to have any adverse archaeological impact and archaeology does not need to be considered further for the proposed development.

UNITED UTILITIES:

Site drainage should be in accordance with the national drainage hierarchy. Advice on potential for property, assets and infrastructure within the application site.

ADDITIONAL REPRESENTATIONS:

Two responses received from interested parties objecting to the proposal on the following grounds:

• Loss of privacy • Impact on the landscape, Read Hall Estate and Park and open countryside; • Potential for landslip, subsidence and damage due to significant earth removal required to build the proposed new dwelling making the surrounding terrain unstable; • All the current residential dwellings in the nearby area, excluding Read Hall, were converted from existing structures, principally disused farm buildings; • The most recent conversion, Larchwood, is a significant distance from the other existing dwellings and is relatively isolated in its setting and therefore has less visual impact; • The 2018 application has been refenced as justification for this application, this was originally rejected with the history of the estate Grade 2* listed Read Hall and significance of the historic parkland are still relevant today; • The applicant states the proposed development will be constructed on a vacant or infill plot – our understanding that this area has never been designated as such and is most definitely not an infill plot. Indeed we are advised that the land has been used for the gazing of sheep and cattle from the nearby farm • The application refers to the granting of planning permission 3/2021/0011 and concludes this should be approved on the same basis, this is different to the proposal to build a new dwelling in open countryside within the setting on a significant, historic parkland that is the Read Hall Estate; • Policies DMG2, DME4 and DMH3 strongly support our objection; • It is plain to see from the plans that the dwelling will be clearly conspicuous from Hammond Drive and The Stables; • According to the site plan the dwelling would be built at approximately 3m above road level at this lowest point and in full view of passing vehicles and pedestrian. Whilst Hammond Drive is a private road the public has a right of access to walk along it; • More importantly is the height of the proposed dwelling and The Stables which would remove any privacy that currently exists. The Stables is 131.69m above sea level and the new dwelling would be built at 136.94m. A difference of 5+m thus the two bedrooms at the eastern end would be overlooked from outside of the proposed new dwelling and possibly from the kitchen/lounge/dining room due to the height issue and the proposed stone patio area as there is only a rail fence separating the two plots; and • The Stable would lose its existing open parkland outlook.

Read every report as text, not just the decision

Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.

Papers for this item

Kept in our archive, download once signed in
PDF
3/2023/0447: Land off Hammond Drive Read BB12 7REReport 242 KB DownloadRead as text

At this meeting

Whole meeting

Who was there

13 of 22 attended
A(
Councillor Anthony (Tony) AustinCommittee Member, present
SB
Councillor Susan BibbyChair, present
DB
Councillor Derek BrocklehurstCommittee Member, present
IB
Councillor Ian BrownCommittee Member, present
SB
Councillor Stella Brunskill JPVice-Chair, present
LE
Councillor Louise EdgeCommittee Member, present
SF
Councillor Stewart FletcherCommittee Member, present
MF
Councillor Mark FrenchCommittee Member, present
SH
Councillor Simon HoreCommittee Member, present
KH
Councillor Kevin Horkin MBECommittee Member, present
SO
Councillor Simon O'RourkeCommittee Member, apologies
J(
Councillor James (Jim) RogersonCommittee Member, apologies

All 22 on the meeting page

On this subject at Ribble Valley

Search all
  1. 3/2023/0447 - Land off Hammond Drive Read BB12 7REThis decision
  2. 3/2025/0997 - Land off Henthorn Road Clitheroe BB7 3BYDeferred
  3. 3/2025/1006 - Land off Pendle Road Clitheroe BB7 1JHDeferred
  4. 3/2025/0196 - Land off Longsight Road LanghoRefused
  5. 3/2023/0540 - Land off Chapel Hill (Hall Barn Drive) Longridge PR3 2YBDeferred
  6. 3/2024/0076 - Land off Hammond Drive Read BB12 7RERefused

More from Ribble Valley Planning and Development

All decisions
MeetingDecisionOutcome
27 Aug 2026 3/2025/0801 - Land to east of Salesbury View WilpshireRESOLVED THAT COMMITTEE: REFUSE PLANNING PERMISSION for the following reasons: 1. The proposed development would be o... Refused Open
27 Aug 2026 3/2022/0317 - Land at Higher Standen Farm and Part Littlemoor Farm ClitheroeRESOLVED THAT COMMITTEE: GRANT planning permission subject to the following condition(s): 1. Unless explicitly requir... Approved Open
27 Aug 2026 3/2026/0442 - Castle Museum Clitheroe Castle Castlegate Clitheroe BB7 1AZRESOLVED THAT COMMITTEE: GRANT planning permission subject to the following condition(s): The development hereby perm... Approved Open
27 Aug 2026 3/2025/0997 - Land off Henthorn Road Clitheroe BB7 3BYRESOLVED THAT COMMITTEE: Application deferred to enable an alternative access directly off Henthorn Road to serve the... Deferred Open
27 Aug 2026 3/2026/0230 - Land to the south of Ribblesdale Primary School west and north of Higher Standen DriveRESOLVED THAT COMMITTEE: DEFER AND DELEGATE to the Director of Economic Development and Planning for approval subject... Deferred Open

We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies