RESOLVED THAT COMMITTEE: Refuse planning permission for the following reasons: 1. The development is considered to have an adverse visual impact on the landscape and locality, and a detrimental effect on the character of the local area, by virtue of the removal of a significant number of trees and the substantial earthworks that have been undertaken including the formation of the ditch and mound (bund) which is considered to be over-bearing and out of scale and character in a rural setting. This is in conflict with key statement EN1, EN2, EN3 and EN4 and policies DMG1, DMG2, DME2 and DME3 of the Ribble Valley Core Strategy. 2. The development involves excavating a trench immediately adjacent to Martholme Viaduct, a Grade II Listed Building, resulting in removal of fill material abutting the viaduct and exposure of stonework at risk of deterioration. Insufficient information (such as an engineering report) has been submitted to demonstrate that the development would preserve the structural integrity of the designated heritage asset, as such the proposal is in conflict with key statement EN5 and policy DME4 of the Ribble Valley Core Strategy.
Word for word from the decision Ribble Valley published for this meeting.Source: democracy.ribblevalley.gov.uk
RECOMMENDATION FOR PLANNING AND DEVELOPMENT COMMITTEE
APPROVAL
DATE: 7 December 2023 REF: SK CHECKED BY: LH
APPLICATION REF: 3/2022/1129
GRID REF: SD 375770 434060
DEVELOPMENT DESCRIPTION:
RETROSPECTIVE CHANGE OF USE WITH MINOR ENGINEERING WORKS AND ASSOCIATED LANDSCAPING WORKS FOR THE REUSE OF THE FORMER RAILWAY EMBANKMENT AND TRACK BED TO FORM AN INFORMAL RECREATIONAL AMENITY AREA IN ASSOCIATION WITH THE ADJACENT HOLIDAY PARK. BRIDGE HEY WOOD CARAVAN PARK, DUNKIRK FARM, READ BB12 7RR CONSULTEE RESPONSES/ REPRESENTATIONS MADE:
PARISH COUNCIL:
Read Parish Council object to the application on the following grounds:
1. In the planning application it is stated that no trees were on the site however it appears multiple mature (70-80yrs+) trees have been removed from the site. 2. The removed woodland formed part of a natural ecosystem with a wealth of biodiversity and wildlife which has seen major impact from the development. 3. The Ditch and Bund formed block access to the Viaduct which is necessary for Railway Paths to perform maintenance on the Viaduct and ensure safety. This provides no additional protection from trespass as there is already a large metal fence in place. This right of access is noted on the land registry documentation (dated 12.10.1979). The ditch also holds potential to cause damage to the viaduct itself. 4. In the Ribble Valley's Local Plan (7.6.6) it is stated that "The site should blend into the landscape and be capable of being screened from both local and more distant viewpoints" and "Advantage should be taken of minor variations in topography and existing natural features, such as trees and hedgerows, should be used to sub-divide or screen the site. Particular importance will be given to the protection of views from footpaths and high level roads. The internal layout of the site should take advantage of natural features and be supplemented when necessary by further landscaping and new tree planting. This will both help to absorb the site into the landscape and create a pleasant internal appearance. Planning permission should therefore not be granted if a site presents an unacceptable intrusion into the landscape and cannot be satisfactorily screened from local and high viewpoints." The removal of healthy mature trees is contrary to this. 5. The planning documents note a footpath which travels under the Viaduct, this is not a footpath owned by the Caravan Park and actually belongs to Railway Paths
LANCASHIRE COUNTY COUNCIL HIGHWAYS (LOCAL HIGHWAYS AUTHORITY):
Initial response - Lancashire County Council acting as the Local Highway Authority (LHA) does not consider that the application as submitted fully assesses the highway impact of the proposed development and further information is required.
The LHA have reviewed the supporting information and are aware that the proposal will use a part of an existing track leading from the caravan park as part of the nature trail. The LHA require the LHAs Public Rights of Way team to comment whether the usability of the trail is suitable for the proposal.
Furthermore, as part of the proposal, works are going to be undertaken adjacent to the viaduct which is described in the Cover Letter as "the works undertaken involve the excavation of a channel and mound adjacent to the viaduct." The LHA require further information regarding what type of works are going to be undertaken adjacent to the viaduct, with the LHA needing to ensure that any works will not destabilise the viaduct and impact upon Lancashire County Councils land.
As the works have been completed already, photographs and a description of the works undertaken adjacent to the viaduct will suffice in this case.
Final response – Having seen the photographs no objection is raised. THE COAL AUTHORITY:
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.