RESOLVED THAT COMMITTEE: REFUSE planning permission for the following reason:- 1. The proposal would lead to the creation of a new residential dwelling in the defined open countryside without sufficient justification insofar that it has not been adequately demonstrated that the proposal would meet any of the exception criteria including meeting a local housing need or providing regeneration benefits. A new dwelling on this site would introduce further urbanisation and detract from the rural character. Furthermore, the siting of the application site outside of the defined settlement area of Wiswell means that future occupants would likely be reliant on a private motor vehicle. Therefore, the proposal fails to comply with Key Statement DS1, DS2 and DMI2 and Policies DMG2, DMH3 and DMG3 of the Ribble Valley Core Strategy 2008 – 2028 as well as the National Planning Policy Framework.
Word for word from the decision Ribble Valley published for this meeting.Source: democracy.ribblevalley.gov.uk
RECOMMENDATION FOR PLANNING AND DEVELOPMENT COMMITTEE
REFUSAL
DATE: 18 April 2024 REF: BT CHECKED BY: LH
APPLICATION REF: 3/2024/0170
GRID REF: SD 375248 438238
DEVELOPMENT DESCRIPTION:
PERMISSION IN PRINCIPLE APPLICATION FOR ONE NEW DWELLING AT BRENTWOOD, PENDLETON ROAD, WISWELL, BB7 9BZ CONSULTEE RESPONSES/ REPRESENTATIONS MADE:
PARISH COUNCIL:
Wiswell Parish Council wish to record that they are not in favour of the proposed small scale residential development outlined in the most recent planning submission. Objections cited to the initial application still hold true (building on land currently used for agricultural purposes which has no previous building history other than a small wooden shed). In addition, we notice that the most recent application suggests that the location is part of the extended domestic curtilage of the existing bungalow. We have no evidence to support this claim.
LANCASHIRE COUNTY COUNCIL HIGHWAYS:
No objections.
UNITED UTILITIES:
No objections subject to adherence with standing advice.
ADDITIONAL REPRESENTATIONS:
None received.
1. Introduction
1.1The application is being brought to Planning and Development Committee as a result of a Member call-in request received from Councillor Birtwhistle. The planning reason(s) stated for bringing this to Committee is that whilst outside the main settlement boundary, this application should be considered infill between existing dwellings.
2. Site Description and Surrounding Area
2.1The application relates to a detached bungalow property located on the North-eastern outskirts of Wiswell. Access to the application site is from Pendleton Road via a driveway which terminates at the property’s integral garage. The application property comprises front and rear garden areas with an expanse of additional land in the applicant’s ownership extending to the North-east and North-west of the application property. The wider area comprises a mixture of isolated dwellings, woodland, agricultural land and open countryside.
3. Proposed Development for which consent is sought
3.1Permission in Principle is sought for the construction of a new dwelling. The proposed dwelling would be sited directly adjacent to the North-east of the property known as Brentwood on land in the applicant’s ownership. The application is a resubmission of previously refused permission in principle application 3/2023/0947.
4. Relevant Planning History
3/2023/0947: Permission In Principle application for one new dwelling (Refused) 3/2023/0566: Proposed new vehicular access. Resubmission of application 3/2023/0038 (Approved)
3/2023/0038: Proposed new vehicular access (Approved)
5. Relevant Policies
Key Statement DS1: Development Strategy Key Statement DS2: Sustainable development Key statement H2: Housing Balance
Policy DMG1: General considerations Policy DMG2: Strategic Considerations Policy DMG3: Transport and Mobility Policy DMH3: Dwellings In The Open Countryside And AONB
National Planning Policy Framework (NPPF) National Planning Practice Guidance
6. Assessment of Proposed Development
6.1Principle:
6.1.1 Permission in Principle applications may only deal with the principle of development. Any other details relating to any other material planning consideration are to be dealt with within any future Technical Details application.
6.1.2 Key statement DS1 of the Ribble Valley Borough Council Core Strategy sets out the spatial vision for the Borough as follows:
The majority of new housing development will be:
• concentrated within an identified strategic site located to the South of Clitheroe towards the A59; and • the principle settlements of:
o Clitheroe; o Longridge; and o Whalley
In the 23 remaining Tier 2 Village settlements, which are the less sustainable of the 32 defined settlements, development will need to meet proven local needs or deliver regeneration benefits.
6.1.3 In addition, Policy DMG2 of the Core Strategy states:
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.