Resolved
RESOLVED THAT COMMITTEE: REFUSE planning permission for the following reasons: 1. The proposed uPVC windows on the front, rear and side elevations, the dark grey cladding on the front dormer and rear gables, the rear wall enclosing the first floor terraced area and balcony areas in the absence of any suitable mitigation, the lighting scheme and the proposed larch cladding to the rear stairwell, are prominent, incongruous, and conspicuous and result in a harmful impact upon the character and appearance of Whalley Conservation Area and the setting of nearby listed buildings namely 10 – 16 (consecutive) Church Lane and the Church of Mary and All Saints. This is contrary to The Planning (Listed Buildings and Conservation Areas) Act 1990, Key Statement EN5 and Policies DME4 and DMG1 of the Ribble Valley Core Strategy 2008 – 2028 as well as the National Planning Policy Framework. 2. The proposal fails to demonstrate that the scheme does not result in significant measurable harm to the residential amenities of the occupiers of numbers 4 - 8 (consecutive) Church Lane by virtue of overlooking and loss of privacy from the first floor roof terraced area. In addition, the proposed lighting scheme would have an unacceptable impact on neighbouring properties 6 and 7 Church Lane, by virtue of the resultant light pollution. This would undermine and diminish the enjoyment of the occupiers of the properties contrary to Policy DMG1 of the Ribble Valley Core Strategy 2008 – 2028 as well as the National Planning Policy Framework. 3. The proposed uPVC windows on the front, rear and side elevations, dark grey cladding on the front dormer and rear gables, rear wall enclosing the first floor terraced area and balcony area in the absence of any suitable mitigation, the lighting scheme and the proposed larch cladding to the rear stairwell, results in an incongruous, unsympathetic, and discordant form of development, that fails to respond positively to the visual character of the area contrary to Policy DMG1 of the Ribble Valley Core Strategy 2008 – 2028 and the National Planning Policy Framework. Councillor M Hindle returned to the meeting.